Just when i was about to give up Nickels

FrenchCreoleCoin · Jul 27, 2012

I hadn't found anything in Nickels for a month, last roll produces 1945 War Nickel and an 1925 Buffalo! Very pumped!

Nickel Searcher 219 · Jul 27, 2012

Dude i found a 1918 buffalo and 2 war nicks this week.I can only do 50$ at a time so I can only do 1-2 boxes a week.Nickels are great here in Missouri.and congrats on your finds.

FrenchCreoleCoin · Jul 27, 2012

Nickel Searcher 219 said:
Dude i found a 1918 buffalo and 2 war nicks this week.I can only do 50$ at a time so I can only do 1-2 boxes a week.Nickels are great here in Missouri.and congrats on your finds.

Congrats back at ya! Sound like ur doing pretty good with small amounts! Keep at it

Nickel Searcher 219 · Jul 27, 2012

Yeah i am waiting til I get 14 war nicks to trade my local coin store for a Morgan Dollar.

FrenchCreoleCoin · Jul 27, 2012

Nickel Searcher 219 said:
Yeah i am waiting til I get 14 war nicks to trade my local coin store for a Morgan Dollar.

That sounds like the way to go! Those Morgan's are only going up

Nickel Searcher 219 · Jul 27, 2012

Yeah and I dont have any....YET.

jnb1994 · Jul 27, 2012

Are the morgan's supposed to have a premium or something? I got 7 of them and 10 peace at a bank for face. Two of my morgans were key date so the guy at my coin shop offered more than spot for those (still less than they probably were worth though) and spot for all the others. Is he ripping me off?

FrenchCreoleCoin · Jul 27, 2012

jnb1994 said:
Are the morgan's supposed to have a premium or something? I got 7 of them and 10 peace at a bank for face. Two of my morgans were key date so the guy at my coin shop offered more than spot for those (still less than they probably were worth though) and spot for all the others. Is he ripping me off?

It just depends on the coin, you need to know the numismatic value in order to know if he's ripping u off, plus he has to make money too so you'll never get top dollar from the coin shop

MrSchulz · Jul 27, 2012

I pulled a 25 p buff yesterday. Got a dateless today. Results coming soon

BuffaloBoy · Jul 27, 2012

nice job, gotta love those silver war nics and buffalo nickels! especially ones with dates!
hh
buff(my favorite coin: buffalo nickels)

mercury1 · Jul 27, 2012

jnb1994 said:
Are the morgan's supposed to have a premium or something? I got 7 of them and 10 peace at a bank for face. Two of my morgans were key date so the guy at my coin shop offered more than spot for those (still less than they probably were worth though) and spot for all the others. Is he ripping me off?

I would keep those silver dollars. Would be about the last crh find I would part with. JMO.

SilverForBrains · Jul 28, 2012

jnb1994 said:
Are the morgan's supposed to have a premium or something? I got 7 of them and 10 peace at a bank for face. Two of my morgans were key date so the guy at my coin shop offered more than spot for those (still less than they probably were worth though) and spot for all the others. Is he ripping me off?

Morgans always go for a premium, peace dollars too but not as much. Morgans are always going to be worth at least $25 a piece, regardless of how low silver goes. Right now you could sell em for $30-$40 on ebay if they're in ok condition. If you want to know if you're being ripped off or not, all you have to do is search on ebay for the coin and use the "advance search" option and click "completed trades only". This will show you all the auctions that have ended for that coin, and is a price guideline. He will give you less than this, that is normal, but not like half the value or anything