Various dates seem to be given, but looks like it was originally built between 1856-1857 as a Union Lutheran Evangelical church, disused and abandoned in 1980. It transitioned to a private studio/loft property in recent times, but was condemned by local officials in March this year, following unauthorised excavation of a basement the previous year, resulting in partial collapse. The owner was ordered to properly secure, repair, or demolish it.
Last changed hands in 2021 for $45,000 (the realtor seems to believe it was built in 1888, but perhaps that was the last addition/extension to the earlier existing church):