Real or Fake

[culverjb]

I want to know what everyone else thinks about this CS Belt buckle

Thanks

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

A Handbook of Civil War Bullets and Cartridges - Grab it through Amazon!

[Tpmetal]

im no expert but it looks good to me?

 

[Carolina Tom]

Looks pretty good to me...

Give us some details on the find. Do you think it is a repop?

 

[USMC Reaper]

No experience in this realm but it has that "real" look all about it, congrats!

 

[culverjb]

It was bought from a individual that dug it supposedly that's why I have my concerns.

 

[Carolina Tom]

The green patina looks good... hard to fake that.

I am by no means qualified to judge, hopefully someone with more experience will chime in.

 

[RGINN]

I don't know all the particulars about those buckles. In the pics, the corrosion and patina look like the real deal to me. Someone who deals in buying and selling relics would know more about what can be faked. At least it doesn't have a bullet embedded in it, so that's one thing. Hope it's the real deal!

 

[foiler]

Have to examine it to tell. The brass is a sure give away if you know what to look for. A photo can't show what needs to be seen but, for my eye in this photo the buckle looks a bit thin. What I mean is the oval shape is may not be true to the original. I can't remember what the measurements are for a real CSA but you can look them up. If it measure true then your half way there. Most repops are a bit off.

 

[culverjb]

Great I will look up the measurements. Thank you

 

[chub]

Please keep us posted.

Chub

 

[CASPER-2]

probably easily over a $1000 buckle if real - patina like that can be faked
though viewing the pic - to me it looks real - hope you got it at a good price
hope it turns out to be genuine

 

[smokeythecat]

It's really hard to tell these days. It should be a match for the documented examples. People shy away from purchasing plates that cannot be matched to exact known original plates. You need to match it 100% to an original. Numerous books are available. There are numerous reference books out there. Also, the hooks have to match. Good luck.

 

[culverjb]

Do you know the exact dimensions of that type of buckle?

 

[culverjb]

Here are my exact dimensions
Weight 162.35 g or 5.72oz
Length 84.44 mm
Width 51.66 mm

 

[coinman123]

I have read articles of people in China faking ancient brass artifacts and adding a very realistic patina.The patina is very similar to many fake ancient artifacts and coins I have seen posted on other forums. That does not mean your piece is fake though, just a thought to consider though.

The artifacts below have a fake patina.

 

[coinman123]

My vote is that your piece is real. I have seen fake buckles with similar patinas, but the buckles themselves always look off. I found a similar buckle for sale on a reproduction website, but the buckle design looks off. I have also seen very similar real buckles. It is hard to tell, I recommend taking it to an expert.

I would guess there is a 70% chance that your buckle is real, if it is a fake it is very well done.

Fake Buckle


Real Buckle

 

[creskol]

I don't like saying this, but i am pretty sure it is a reproduction. I am pretty sure the Confederates only had one solder filled oval buckle with arrow hooks, but I don't recall that it looked like that..

 

[creskol]

Here are my exact dimensions
Weight 162.35 g or 5.72oz
Length 84.44 mm
Width 51.66 mm

The one plate they had that looked similar was 88mm long by 59mm wide.

 

[smokeythecat]

I will double check my books later today after my happy nap. Was out digging that pesky silver again this am. It will take awhile to see if there is a match there.

 

[Mud Hut]

I will double check my books later today after my happy nap. Was out digging that pesky silver again this am. It will take awhile to see if there is a match there.

I am not finding anything to match in my books. Have you had any luck, Smokey?