It doesn't have to make economic sense. No more than detecting makes economic sense. People trap because they enjoy trapping. It's an outdoor pursuit, and one that can pay for itself.
Heck, a couple of years ago, in a town not far from my home, a government trapper put out an exploding cyanide device for coyotes. This device was placed within a 1/2 mile of homes! So, along comes a 15 year old kid with his dog. The dog uproots the device and it goes off, spraying the dog with cyanide. The dog dies....the kid is sickened but survives. He also has continuing health issues. The guy putting out the device got off scott-free, though he violated several rules about the placing of the device. These devices are still being used, and if you're running around BLM lands, you could easily run into one, and under the right circumstances, it could kill you...not just your dog. So why no outrage? Personally, I see no valid reason for the use of these to kill coyotes.
Jim
Place I detect has a guy trapping there. There are fluorescent markers set very close to each trap he sets.
Jim, I have never heard of cyanide devices, exploding no less. That is truly a criminal device. For a recreational pursuit, a non selective trap, left out there to catch anything that sniffs around, is a far cry from swinging a metal detector. The person may gain tremendous enjoyment from it, but IMO it's careless, thoughtless, and selfish. If you cause harm to innocent creatures, like someone's dog, I strongly suggest a different form of recreation. This isn't the early 1800's, there are people, kids, and pets everywhere. Stupid dog, sure hoped he learned from that. Ass backward logic.
Doesn't matter if it's a far cry. It's legal, and people have done it for 100's of years. I never have, just to set the record straight. And, the really good trappers I know go to great pains to do their sets where there's little chance of harming a pet. But there are jerks in every activity, and it pays to know what's going on. I also worry about Heidi being shot when I'm out in the boondocks. She has the aspect of a coyote, though no skilled hunter would mistake her for one. Still, it's just one more thing I need to be aware of. When I head up a canyon, I always check to see if there's evidence of others being in there that day. If there are, I usually go somewhere else.....especially during hunting season. Fortunately, I live where there are millions of acres to roam around in, so I can pick and choose.
Jim
Well around here nobody in their right mind lets their pets wander outside anymore. About 15 years ago dogs in the area started just disappearing. After that, nobody let them out anymore. Then our culture changed and people got smaller breeds and those are kept inside. Years ago I used to see cats and dogs running loose, lots of them laying dead in the road too. It's been forever since I've seen either a cat or dog dead in the road, and pets unfortunately will run right into a road and get hit. With the coyotes and eagles around, the cat owners don't let their cats out (I certainly don't) and it is actually against the law to let a dog run loose. I think it's been at least 10 years since a stray dog came on my lawn. At least ten years since I SAW one on the lawn, that is. I see people with them on leashes going down the street all the time. I also hear one or two barking from time to time in the distance. Now coyote, bobcat, mountain lion, opossum, raccoons, eagles, etc., yes, they run or fly loose.