1) You stated it when you watched that cat move up and down wind. See they use
their sense of smell and will work both in and out of the path of air travel. They aren't
smart enough to understand it.
2) Last the only paperwork you should be worried about in the mountains is toilet paper. Stop worrying about
live and let live. I follow the 3 S's rule. Shoot, Shovel, and SHUT UP.
I have been a guide in Idaho for more years than I wish to count and the behavior you calif's have about cats is pure
nonsense. Shoot them Hunt them and they will retreat to the areas where Man doesn't like to go and there will be a LOT
less of your poor little puppies and kitties going missing every year LOL.
I think you've got me confused with another person on that quote, and how/why the cat uses his sense
of smell to his benefit. I disagree about the "not smart enough" part. Hunted and tracked a lot of cats
that were damn smart, and as a guide I have little doubt that you've chased a few smart ones yourself.
As for being from "Calif", well..I'm afraid you've been watching too many Hollywood TV shows. I was
born and grew up in a small horse ranching community set back in the foothills of Orange and
Riverside counties. This was hot, dry country in the Summer, and we never once took a day off work
cause it was too hot. From 16 on I've been hunting predators, be they a calf eating Coyote, lamb
stealin' Badger to the Fox or Bobcat raiding the chicken house. In the last 35 years I've called in and
shot nearly a thousand coyotes, hundreds of bobcat and a laundry list of other fur bearing
meat eaters. Spent several years hunting with an ADC Trapper down in S. Oregon, and in that
time we had to shoot far more domestic dogs that were killing sheep than any other critter. In
most cases the ranchers would think we were nuts when we told 'em it was free-roaming domestic
dogs out running in packs and not a cougar or coyote.
That's not to say we didn't have to hunt down anything else, but when it was a wild critter doing the
killin' we wanted to make damn sure we downed the "PA", or problem animal. I think Herb was
half-human and half-wildman...lol. More than once I knew him to spend days on end tracking
a single cougar all over hell's half-acre just to be sure he got the right cat, and not the ones
staying in the hills and doing their job to keep the deep population in check. That's the man
I learned to trap from, and he was the best there was at working with critters but he never
cared much for people...at all. Unfortunately, he's gone on ahead now and I sure do miss
his fine meals (which all looked and tasted the same, no matter the ingredients..lol)
I've killed far more than my share of critters, and just because I don't care to take another
animals life unless there is no other option does not make me the least bit like some
ARA who has entirely different motivations than what I personally do. I've had cougar pop out
of a shrub 20 feet in front of me as I sat there working a predator call. I had a 12ga. pointed
at his head, and it could have gone either way for a few minutes there..lol Fortunately, I didn't
have to kill that one, either. Cougar are a "Mountain Man's Veal", and I've chowed on more
than one, but for me I never saw the reason to shoot one for meat when a nice fat 2yo.
doe would go a lot further.
You feel the way you do based on your own motivations and reasoning and there ain't
a damn thing wrong with that. Still, just because someone disagrees with you, and has
formed their own opinions based on their own years of personal experience does not
necessarily place us on opposing sides of an issue. We just look at it differently.
All the best to ya, and hope a good season lies ahead for you this Fall.