People may be suckers for marketing, but I don't think the ATP is a bad machine. Yeah, a lot of people were probably sold the minute they saw it on the show. But who cares to each their own.....
I can tell you that I will never own a Minelab. Not because I don't think they are good machines- they seem very impressive- but 1) I can't afford one, and 2) it's hard for me to buy something that has an AMERICAN MADE competition.
The 3 detectors I had it narrowed down to when i first decided to get into the hobby were actually:
1)AT Pro
2)Fisher F5
3)X-Terra 505
All were in the same price range but the 505 was out as soon as I found out the other 2 were actually made here! Wow! I can't believe more of you guys aren't happy about this?!?! This is America...... and all this time I been thinking they we don't build anything anymore except guns and cars...... I had to double check because I knew these things were electronic!
Come on!!! I mean holy $#!+ WE REALLY MAKE SOMETHING ELECTRONIC

?? I didn't just pull a Marty McFly and get zapped back to 1955- we actually, really, in real life, in 2013 make something that takes batteries in the United States of America!
I'm still astounded. And it makes me proud and ashamed at the same time if the makes any sense at all.
So, anyway....... why did I go with the Fisher?
I flipped a coin.