shell stays preserved, often patinates, well in SOME FL soils. In my experience a heavier humic layer without much oxygen preserves both bone and shell. Plus, they often used the hardest parts of the shells to make tools.
Shell that is exposed to weather elements often just deteriorates away. If shell is rolled around in surf or is in water it gets abraded to death and/or algae and pH, etc. eats slowly away. In fact, even great preserved shell, once it hits air, starts getting chalky...well most of it! Shell middens and areas where people lived usually have more of this humic component mixed in with broken shell and other human debitage. I think it all adds up to great preservation. The shells on top may even be decomposing and causing pH differences,,,,, i bet someone has done a thesis on that!!!! I'd love to see the pH, O2 levels, and other measurements from top to bottom of a shell midden, or any wet site. Would be very different from an upland dry site. In some wet sites and even shell middens the pottery sometimes crumbles as soon as it pops out, especiallly if it gets wet afterward.
The nicest areas I've ever seen were dark, black midden soil mixed with lenses of shell debitage, all jumbled up for centuries. I have pics somewhere that show the walls and washouts of middens after storms/hurricanes.
What freaks me out, GB, is finding what looks like very weathered (but worked/ground) shell, usually clam, where it's not expected, I think they used shell for chalk itself, either to some kind of ethnobotanic effect (WOW!) mixed with something, or added to food, or paint.....heck I don't know, but I've found ground shell fairly deep and insitu, as well as many small columnellas in the same places I've always thought they were crab-picks, LOL. I expect to see drill like columnellas and deteriorating clamshell in the surf, but not up into a site.... So many sites gone now, wonder if archies ever figured some of this stuff out.
Hey, calcium carbonate is a good acid reducer, maybe they had a lot of indigestion and heartburn back in the day!!!
It's the #1 type of medication bottle I've found in dumps!!


?