Well he came here in 1867 but I will have to read more to find out exact date I'm sure someone will post something to. It is deffinatly not a machine made bottle though
I'd think you've got a good one there, being that it's from a small local brewery and they didn't last long. It's something I'd think a collector would really want, especially if you found someone who specializes in NE Ohio or Cleveland area breweries.