What's new

METERIOTE identification help

necro92983

Tenderfoot
Joined
Jan 8, 2026
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Golden Thread
0
hi all. i am new to the forum and need some help. i am in the process of purchasing a bunch of meteorites and am new to the hobby. i am dealing with someone new located in the south who came across a large group of meteorites. i am looking to buy a bunch but need some help verifying what type these might be and are actual meteorites. they look good and the guy seems to know his stuff. just want a second opinion. ty

i did purchase one already and it seems to be heavy for its size ( which is good i hear).
 

Attachments

  • met1.webp
    met1.webp
    155.5 KB · Views: 111
  • met2.webp
    met2.webp
    148.8 KB · Views: 84
  • met3.webp
    met3.webp
    110.2 KB · Views: 95
  • met333.webp
    met333.webp
    293 KB · Views: 85
Welcome to Tnet. You are wise to seek advice before parting with your money (albeit you already seem to have made one purchase). The good things about advice are that it often comes for free and, even when you have it, you don’t have to accept it. I hope you accept my advice as a long-time collector and meteorite enthusiast, which is as follows:

I would be HIGHLY suspicious of someone who claims to have “come across a large group of meteorites” and is seeking to sell them, unless:

- They are from a locality that represents a known strewnfield.

- And the person concerned has some ‘credentials’, either of a scientific nature or by reputational recognition in the collector community.

- Or is an IMCA member

- Or can provide documentary evidence from professional testing by a laboratory with appropriate credentials.

I have said it frequently here that meteorites cannot usually be identified from pictures alone, but that pictures can sometimes suggest when specimens are not meteorites. My strong feeling is that the specimens in your pictures are not meteorites.

I would add that anyone with meteoritic knowledge would know that finds such as those claimed by your seller would, if they are meteorites, substantially increase in value if they were submitted for typological assessment and (if appropriate) granted a formal name in the MetSoc database as new finds. Only a fool or a charlatan would sell them without such attributions.
 
i am dealing with someone new located in the south who came across a large group of meteorites. i am looking to buy a bunch but need some help verifying what type these might be and are actual meteorites.

I would strongly encourage you to follow Red Coat's excellent advice.
 
hi all. i am new to the forum and need some help. i am in the process of purchasing a bunch of meteorites and am new to the hobby. i am dealing with someone new located in the south who came across a large group of meteorites. i am looking to buy a bunch but need some help verifying what type these might be and are actual meteorites. they look good and the guy seems to know his stuff. just want a second opinion. ty

i did purchase one already and it seems to be heavy for its size ( which is good i hear).
Sending you a private message with the email of a detectorist who hunts and buys/sells meteorites for a living. He'll be able to give you answers to your questions. Anyone else wanting this persons name, feel free to message me, I didnt ask if it was ok to post this email publicly, just to reply to the OP on his questions.
 
I agree with Red-coat, however, those are NOT meteorites.
 
Sending you a private message with the email of a detectorist who hunts and buys/sells meteorites for a living. He'll be able to give you answers to your questions. Anyone else wanting this persons name, feel free to message me, I didnt ask if it was ok to post this email publicly, just to reply to the OP on his questions.
I got the ok to post their email so anyone interested in contacting this person regarding buying or selling, or knowledge about meteorites can contact them at keithandana@gmail.com Let them know Phil sent you
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom