What's new

Missing Treasure Map sterotype..

Curiousity

Jr. Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2025
Messages
56
Reaction score
62
Golden Thread
0
Edgar Allan Poe started it with the Missing Treasure map syndrome in his short story "The Old Bug"
Nearly 50 year later Robert Lewis Stevenson wrote "Treasure Island" [still one of my favorite reading books..the only good adaptation was a 1970's cartoon!]
ALways legends of Missing treasure...with the lost Treasure map....The Lost Dutchman Mine of Arizona; The alleged Rommel Treasure of World war II
Milton Cantiff was the cartoonist for over 40 years.....of two popular comics about Fly boy officers....Americans Terry and the Pirates October 22, 1934, to February 25, 1973 and Steave Canyon January 13, 1947, until June 4, 1988. Both were so painfully ethnic sterotyped....it was almost painful to read them te evil asian dragon Lady,,,,the pgeon speaking chinese servant...the 90 year old survivor of Custer 7th cavalry wandering around Asia....
Terry and the Pirates in 1934 a 10 year old american boy finds a treasure map and goes off to asia....for the next 40 years.....

Al CApp did a hilariuos spoof of Steve Canyon in a series called Steve Cantor written by Milton Gontiff [Gontiff is a yiddish word for Thief]}
 
Edgar Allan Poe started it with the Missing Treasure map syndrome in his short story "The Old Bug"
Nearly 50 year later Robert Lewis Stevenson wrote "Treasure Island" [still one of my favorite reading books..the only good adaptation was a 1970's cartoon!]

Edgar Allan Poe’s 1843 short story “The Gold Bug” doesn’t feature an actual treasure map. The plot revolves around an unusual scarab-like beetle with markings that resemble a skull and a scrap of paper used to sketch it which is later found to have a secret message written in invisible ink using a substitution cipher.

The first instance of a treasure map in popular fiction is probably from James Fenimore Cooper's 1849 novel “The Sea Lions” (published more than 30 years before Robert Louis Stevenson’s “Treasure Island.”) The plot revolves around the death of a sailor who leaves behind "two old, dirty and ragged charts", which lead to a seal-hunting paradise in the Antarctic and a location in the West Indies where pirates have buried treasure.

Although buried pirate treasure is a popular literary theme, there are very few documented cases of pirates actually burying treasure, and no reliably documented cases of a historical pirate treasure map [ref: “Under the Black Flag: The Romance and the Reality of Life Among the Pirates” by David Cordingley, 1995.]
 
Edgar Allan Poe’s 1843 short story “The Gold Bug” doesn’t feature an actual treasure map. The plot revolves around an unusual scarab-like beetle with markings that resemble a skull and a scrap of paper used to sketch it which is later found to have a secret message written in invisible ink using a substitution cipher.

The first instance of a treasure map in popular fiction is probably from James Fenimore Cooper's 1849 novel “The Sea Lions” (published more than 30 years before Robert Louis Stevenson’s “Treasure Island.”) The plot revolves around the death of a sailor who leaves behind "two old, dirty and ragged charts", which lead to a seal-hunting paradise in the Antarctic and a location in the West Indies where pirates have buried treasure.

Although buried pirate treasure is a popular literary theme, there are very few documented cases of pirates actually burying treasure, and no reliably documented cases of a historical pirate treasure map [ref: “Under the Black Flag: The Romance and the Reality of Life Among the Pirates” by David Cordingley, 1995.]
True the only knwon case of Documented Buried Treasure by Pirates was William Kidd...on Gardner Island...and that was recovered so as to be used in evidence against him....{yet 1 account claims that generations later Treasure Hunters were still looking for his Treasure even after it had been salvaged! {American Heritage Magazine February 1957] besides reading cargos of what Pirates captured.....animials Hides; slaves; Indigo....ever since Privateer/Pirate Sir Francis Drake captured several Spanish Gallons...which did have treasure.....everyone expects that all Spanish SHips all carried treasure....examples being the Treasure Fleet which was lost off Florida and later salvaged by Mel Fisher.... incidently in aReaders Digiest Collection of Stories for Young People....there was what else Treasure map story.....in which a old seasman leaves his sea chest with his landlady...before vanishing....two boys open up the chest..find a map and dig up treasureleft by Pirate Batholowe Roberts...one loses his fortune through stock speculaption...the other becaome a curtor at a museum....I woundered where this inspiration for the idea came from..then I looked up the author...he was a writer of popular stories [fiction] for young persons!

Then of course the story a lost mine....found once and never found again....
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest Discussions

Back
Top Bottom