Question for all Beale Cipher Enthusiasts

[chalkoutline]

We are dealing with possible vs not possible.
I agree the timing looks impossible which is why i highlighted those events of my timeline in red. However it is not impossible.
Believe me i tried!

 

[souce19]

I don’t have time tonight but I will absolutely check out your timeline. 👍🏻

 

[souce19]

I believe the “impossible” timeline is what forced me to look elsewhere. I want the story to be real and I believe portions of it are. It’s just the traverse back to Virginia like twice and the way they found the gold/silver that I cannot wrap my mind around haha. So I have pivoted and have been analyzing what I believe is true.

 

[chalkoutline]

Here are a couple of other ideas...
1. TB stayed with Robert Morriss and his charismatic personality made him the perfect character to include in a fabricated story.
2. TB actually returned to Virginia a third time and recovered all the treasure caches. There was no need to to continue on to Lynchburg to pick up the locked box.

 

[souce19]

I just read through your timeline. It’s actually great stuff. You’ve researched this particular Beale quite a lot. I agree with your yellow and red highlighted notes. The Supreme Court decision you pulled may be the best information pulled. However, for me, it proves that he could not have been in Colorado if he was actively running his father’s property. This must not be the right Beale or Beale character.

Looking at the “other ideas” portion, I think I can agree with you to an extent that Robert Morriss wasn’t some special person picked out because of his character. But rather because he could be a real traceable person who was little more than a custodian for a potential contingency plan. He just holds the box. If Robert Morriss considered this man a gentleman and was told not to open the box, I bet he wouldn’t. If Robert Morriss did not respect the man at all, he’d open it the second Beale left again.

2) there’s always the possibility that the caches were already recovered. But my question would be, why bury it if you plan to dig it back up soon. From all available information, this entire treasure is a ghost outside of The Beale Letter. So the next question is, was it even truly buried? Or buried in Virginia?

Thoughts?

 

[chalkoutline]

If Robert Morriss provided 5 clues...
1. Name; Thomas Beale
2. He was a Virginian
3. Thought to have lived west of Lynchburg
4. Weathy
5. Well educated

...And there is just ONE TB who meets all five clues; TB Jr. Beautourt
It doesn't make sense to propose another person since they couldn't meet all the clues.

If you then conclude he was in Louisiana and not in Colorado as the story indicates, then the story is made up.

 

[treasure1822]

I agree with your thoughts...the papers do not say "Bedford County" but rather "In the county of Bedford". There were a few words left out as to make what he was saying vague so the people inquiring add assumption seeing the papers were published Bedford county VA.

 

[treasure1822]

"When you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth." Sherlock Holmes...

 

[treasure1822]

MATTHEW 6:1-4
“Beware of practicing your righteousness before other people in order to be seen by them, for then you will have no reward from your Father who is in heaven. “Thus, when you give to the needy, sound no trumpet before you, as the hypocrites do in the synagogues and in the streets, that they may be praised by others. Truly, I say to you, they have received their reward. But when you give to the needy, do not let your left hand know what your right hand is doing, so that your giving may be in secret. And your Father who sees in secret will reward you.

 

[releventchair]

If Robert Morriss provided 5 clues...
1. Name; Thomas Beale
2. He was a Virginian
3. Thought to have lived west of Lynchburg
4. Weathy
5. Well educated

...And there is just ONE TB who meets all five clues; TB Jr. Beautourt
It doesn't make sense to propose another person since they couldn't meet all the clues.

If you then conclude he was in Louisiana and not in Colorado as the story indicates, then the story is made up.

HEART OF LOUISIANA: The Last Buffalo in Louisiana

During the mid 1800’s, when settlers moved into western Louisiana, it was not unusual to see hundreds of buffalo, or bison, roaming through the rolling hills.

www.wafb.com

 

[treasure1822]

View attachment 2257481

HEART OF LOUISIANA: The Last Buffalo in Louisiana

During the mid 1800’s, when settlers moved into western Louisiana, it was not unusual to see hundreds of buffalo, or bison, roaming through the rolling hills.

www.wafb.com

What is the name? I cannot make it out...

 

[souce19]

Memory of L. COURBEY?

 

[releventchair]

What is the name? I cannot make it out...

[ a man named L. C. Curbey who died and was buried here in 1897.]

[And during the winter months, much of that meat came from bison, commonly called buffalo. There’s a reason that Mr. Curbey’s grave is located here on a small hill in the forested landscape.

“His dying wish was that he would be buried where he killed the last buffalo in Louisiana. And this is Mr. Curbey’s grave where he was at when he killed the last buffalo coming up this buffalo run behind us right here,” said Robertson.]