Just saw at the coin store they have a 2000 s 2003s 2005s and 2 other silver proof quarters for sale. They asking $7 a coin for them. Do you think this is a good price? Please let me know.
I personally wouldn't be a buyer at that price, but its probably a pretty fair price. Its not a bargain IMO, but not horribly overpriced either. Melt value is about $6.40 as I type this.
$7+tax is around $7.50. silver is at $35.52 and a silver quarter is $6.42... If you're doing it for an investment, you will break even if silver reaches $41.50... Personally I wouldn't bother.
So far a real "proof", "S" mint, protected coin has more value to a collector than melt value. I don't know how long that will last though. Give someone enough money and they would melt anything.