The Peralta-Fish Map

[Hal Croves]

the fact is was it possible for Fish to kill Ruth for his map and the answer is yes , is there enough evidence to prove it and the answer is again yes if he did write the words on the map. if you can not under stand that its not problem .. we are seeking answer to unsolved question . I am sorry if I am no longer looking for the LDM .I am taking time to go back and under stand how this legend pulled all these other events into its path ..what is funny is the Peralta /Ruth map ,parts of the Peralta /Fish map ,the Peralta stones ,and the Gonzales map all go to the same location ....and yes parts of the 7 maps that clay shared with us ...

Interesting thought.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

A History of Mining on the Kenai Peninsula, Alaska - Grab it through Amazon!

[azdave35]

Thanks. I still got a lot of ground to cover and don't know stuff which you have been long familiar with so please bear with my ignorance.
All that really matters is if the Fish map is what it purports to be.

no problem HBP...

 

[Blindbowman]

in fact there is a point .. if the Peralta Fish map in fact was the second Peralta Ruth map .that would tell us that Ruth had both maps and they match the stones and the Gonzales map ..I know they match but proving it is harder then it looks ...and the more we put the truth back in the right patterns the more we learn about the events that take us back to the things that were lost in the confusion a long the way .. when the whole picture is complete a lot of people will be interested in the story and the history of many different things of these legends ...Fish may have had nothing to do with Ruth's death but lets see where the theory takes us and can it open some of those lock doors they stopped so many from finding their dreams . and heal the pain of those who spent their life times trying to solve these legend ..before the history fades away let us go after it and save it for generations in the future .its up to us . we can not count on others to blasé the trails of our past .. under a blank of rare feathers and woven basket reeds rest a God that once gave his life to try to save his people and was the ehope of the people and here we are the chance to make sure that history is not taken like the greed of gold or silver or to own the land that they grew up on ...and were part of .. there is a very real spirit world and a very real great spirit and we need to show them we still care . !

 

[Hal Croves]

in fact there is a point .. if the Peralta Fish map in fact was the second Peralta Ruth map .that would tell us that Ruth had both maps and they match the stones and the Gonzales map ..I know they match but proving it is harder then it looks ...and the more we put the truth back in the right patterns the more we learn about the events that take us back to the things that were lost in the confusion a long the way .. when the whole picture is complete a lot of people will be interested in the story and the history of many different things of these legends ...Fish may have had nothing to do with Ruth's death but lets see where the theory takes us and can it open some of those lock doors they stopped so many from finding their dreams . and heal the pain of those who spent their life times trying to solve these legend ..before the history fades away let us go after it and save it for generations in the future .its up to us . we can not count on others to blasé the trails of our past .. under a blank of rare feathers and woven basket reeds rest a God that once gave his life to try to save his people and was the ehope of the people and here we are the chance to make sure that history is not taken like the greed of gold or silver or to own the land that they grew up on ...and were part of .. there is a very real spirit world and a very real great spirit and we need to show them we still care . !

I have been looking at Frank Fish and talking to a few locals.
Doesn't seem like the killer type.


Do you have some source or proof to the theory?

 

[Blindbowman]

I have been looking at Frank Fish and talking to a few locals.
Doesn't seem like the killer type.


Do you have some source or proof to the theory?

yes, Waltz wasn't the killer type ether . ! Gold makes men do odd things , take risk they normally would not take ..but this much Gold . drives men insane with greed ...if two men you did not know stood between you and the LDM would you shot them ...?

 

[Blindbowman]

and yes if Frank Fish wrote the words on any one of those maps then the only that could have happened is if he killed Ruth for it ..think about as I said IMHO there is no other way the map would have been with out words .. Ruth did that to protect him self ...if Frank Fish wrote the words on the map then he lied about how he got it ...

 

[Hal Croves]

yes, Waltz wasn't the killer type ether . ! Gold makes men do odd things , take risk they normally would not take ..but this much Gold . drives men insane with greed ...if two men you did not know stood between you and the LDM would you shot them ...?

No.
But I agree with you about Fred C. Dobbs syndrome.

 

[Hal Croves]

and yes if Frank Fish wrote the words on any one of those maps then the only that could have happened is if he killed Ruth for it ..think about as I said IMHO there is no other way the map would have been with out words .. Ruth did that to protect him self ...if Frank Fish wrote the words on the map then he lied about how he got it ...

I am not sure that I follow.
The original map that we are dissecting is not the one that is poorly translated, the one with "notes".
That is a known copy, altered by one of the Legends of Adventure team.

Someone with your intellect should be in a position to offer thoughtful evidence or proof when defaming a man.

Frank did take "several" trips into the Superstitions.
It wouldn't be that difficult to lean the dates.

 

[azdave35]

I am not sure that I follow.
The original map that we are dissecting is not the one that is poorly translated, the one with "notes".
That is a known copy, altered by one of the Legends of Adventure team.

Someone with your intellect should be in a position to offer thoughtful evidence or proof when defaming a man.

Frank did take "several" trips into the Superstitions.
It wouldn't be that difficult to lean the dates.

exactly hal..its pretty easy to hang a rap on someone that is no longer around to defend himself...

 

[azdave35]

I am not sure that I follow.
The original map that we are dissecting is not the one that is poorly translated, the one with "notes".
That is a known copy, altered by one of the Legends of Adventure team.

Someone with your intellect should be in a position to offer thoughtful evidence or proof when defaming a man.

Frank did take "several" trips into the Superstitions.
It wouldn't be that difficult to lean the dates.

greg would know if frank was in the superstitions and when

 

[Hal Croves]

exactly hal..its pretty easy to hang a rap on someone that is no longer around to defend himself...

I think that Frank enjoyed being a local celebrity and showing off his discoveries.
He was well like by local kids, eventually his neighbors (most) and Lake Erie.
Not the hallmark of a sociopath.

Waltz, not so much.

I will say this about Franks murder (suicide), it was the right time and place for it.
Off topic.

 

[Blindbowman]

if all these maps are from one source and it is fishes then how do defend a evidence if it dose prove to true ... I can tell you for a 100 % fact all those maps have the same flaw...! how can you explain that ...? come on lets hear your reasoning ...if you going to tell me I am slandering someone ,then you better have prove he didn't . and you go right and tell me what's wrong with the maps ...I got a better way to end this .. just who cares if he shot a dozen people .... or if he had nothing to do with Waltz death .. were are not try to solve the death rate in the superstitions , we are trying to fill in the blanks ...and I did say IMHO ...we went threw all this a dozen times already it just a waste of my time . I will ready and keep my big mouth shut ,but no more replies . get your answers .....

 

[Al D]

. I will ready and keep my big mouth shut ,but no more replies . get your answers .....

Please Lord, let it be true

 

[azdave35]

Please Lord, let it be true

 

[Hal Croves]

if all these maps are from one source and it is fishes then how do defend a evidence if it dose prove to true ... I can tell you for a 100 % fact all those maps have the same flaw...! how can you explain that ...? come on lets hear your reasoning ...if you going to tell me I am slandering someone ,then you better have prove he didn't . and you go right and tell me what's wrong with the maps ...I got a better way to end this .. just who cares if he shot a dozen people .... or if he had nothing to do with Waltz death .. were are not try to solve the death rate in the superstitions , we are trying to fill in the blanks ...and I did say IMHO ...we went threw all this a dozen times already it just a waste of my time . I will ready and keep my big mouth shut ,but no more replies . get your answers .....

You in some way reached that conclusion but will not or can not explain how.
Which is a great place to leave it.

 

[Hal Croves]

arroyo Colorodo
The red stream/wash?

The two lines, dashes-
"certain number of varas to be measured"
Mahan
O'Higgins

 

[Hal Croves]

arroyo Colorodo
The red stream/wash?

The two lines, dashes-
"certain number of varas to be measured"
Mahan
O'Higgins


View attachment 1756571

And if those dashes do represent the "vara", the map should not have been made before 1823, when it (the vara) "was declared to be the unit of land measurement".

Vara = 33 1/3"

 

[sgtfda]

A red stream or wash would be rich in iron. A good place to look for gold.

 

[Hillbilly Prince]

I think that Frank enjoyed being a local celebrity and showing off his discoveries.
He was well like by local kids, eventually his neighbors (most) and Lake Erie.
Not the hallmark of a sociopath.

Waltz, not so much.

I will say this about Franks murder (suicide), it was the right time and place for it.
Off topic.

I hope you expound on that in the Frank Fish thread.

 

[markmar]

You have to be careful summoning spiirits. You never know which ones are listening
Bowman, I'm not questioning your experiences so don't take offense
So most people here think the Peralta-Fish map is the real deal? But no one has found anything using it. Or maybe people wouldn't announce it anyhow.
If Fish bought the map from the Peraltas...wonder if they thought it was just a generic old map of little value.
Fish didn't find anything with it, or so it appears. Is this the earliest "treasure" map related to the Superstitions?

HBP

IMO the PF map is a generic map which is for the west side of the Superstitions, but not of little value. Is a very cunning made map which has two different codes for two different purposes. Both codes are for angles that should be applied in regards to have the real image of the map.
The first code is for the landmarks in the map ( the three Xs above the word Arrastra ) which says how we have to turn them 30 degrees to the left to have the real image of the region ( also the words which are diagonally written on the map , to go horizontally like the other words ).
The second code is for the mines. What is important to know, is how every code will have to be applied separatelly and not together, like you have two identical maps , one for the landmarks and another for the mines.