Wait for someone else to answer but I don't think either of this is a viable option for that beauty. Give me a minute to think here and I will get back to you budBetter pic. Question - if this is pewter does peroxide work or is lemon juice a better option. I can see a bit of gilt just under the grime, so I'm thinking the lemon juice is the one? Thanks for any help.
That is an absolute beauty my friend and one I've never seen. Is it actually pewter? I don't want to question you but I believe it may be cast brass with gold gilt? If it is then you have a tough decision to make. I use naval jelly on gold gilt but you have to be very very careful. If it looks great I would leave it the hell alone.... And it looks great to me so it prob looks really good in personThanks man. This thing is actually quite a looker in person. Much better than the pic. The "U S" is so friggin clear it's outrageous and all the stars are well defined. Don't you love how you can stick a "whatever" in the case, then come home and find it all over again when you realize what it is?




I'm glad Buck chimed in. I think he's right and you've got a real beauty there that you should prob not mess with. That is a great piece of history and you'd be very upset if you screwed that one up. I think it's early 1800sThat button looks great like it is. I don't think I'd clean it any more. True it might improve. But it might also get much worse. I don't think it's worth taking the chance. GREAT find there! That's not one I see posted very often at all. Best Wishes, Buck