Help Identify button with white glass top

[myrtlebeach]

I recently found this button and could use some help identifying it. It has what seems to be a white glass front on it. Definitely not plastic. The back is heavily corroded and I haven't tried cleaning it with anything other than a toothpick yet. Here is some history on the site it was found on. Lot's of very old bricks, a map from the 1820's identified this to be a home site- thats what drew me to this particular location. The same area had confederate and union soldiers on it at certain times. Any help would be appreciated. And any suggestions on how to clean it up a bit would also be helpful. Thanks

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

How to Research for Treasure Hunting and Metal Detecting From Lead Generation to Vetting - Grab it through Amazon!

[bigfoot1]

I believe I would soak it in mild lemon juice overnight...then warm water dish soap and soft toothbrush.


edit....welcome to tnet..

 

[Bigcypresshunter]

I guess its milk glass. Kinda resembles the Chrysler logo. Does magnet stick to the back?

 

[myrtlebeach]

I guess its milk glass. Kinda resembles the Chrysler logo. Does magnet stick to the back?

Yes a magnet sticks to it. Thanks

 

[HutSiteDigger]

BiggyC is right! Milk glass button. could date anywhere from 1830s too 1900s i would guess. I think these buttons were somewhat popular during Andrew Jacksons time frame? kewl button! I find lot of civil war glass buttons but never found one like the one you have!

Photo below is 19th century Milk glass button!

 

[myrtlebeach]

Thanks for the info. What do you use to clean yours up? On the ones you have do any of them have a makers mark on the backside?

 

[HutSiteDigger]

Here are the ones you find in Civil War sites mainly in hut sites and trash pits! Like I said I have not dug one like yours.. I am sure you are asking how too clean the back of the button off, I would not clean the front off anymore it looks good... Just gently scrap as much dirt as you can off and then try lemon juice or ammonia with soap (you can buy ammonia with soap in it @ Wal-mart do not add soap to ammonia). Other then that good luck.

 

[Bigcypresshunter]

Im afraid to give any cleaning advice bit I dont think water will hurt the milk glass however you dont want to get any liquid inside a hollow button. . The backside can probably not be saved if its thin steel. Tinned iron backs may be thicker and stronger.

If its thin steel back my guess would be 20th century. Tin back 19th c.

 

[Bigcypresshunter]

The rim looks like it may be brass. Is it brass?

 

[surf]

Hello myrtlebeach,

Welcome to TNet, and thanks for showing us this great button. It certainly is rife with symbols. I wonder if it's Masonic, Order of the Holy Sepulchre, or what...

It certainly does look like milk glass. What's the back look like"

 

[myrtlebeach]

The rim looks like it may be brass. Is it brass?

Yes, I do believe the rim is brass. I am fairly certain it is at least 3 pieces. The milk glass, the brass rim and another metal that makes up the back- which is also the most corroded.

 

[Bigcypresshunter]

Breezie could probably date it for you and tell you more

 

[Breezie]

BCH, Thanks for the vote of confidence. I haven't been to TNet in a week because I've been so busy at work and home.

As far as the button is concerned, before I make a call on it, I'd like to see the front cleaned, (semi-wet toothbrush & small dot of Dawn or any dish washing liquid. Also, I'd like to see a close-up pic photographed on any color but white or black. A medium blue or green would be best.

Right now, I'm thinking it could be 1 of 3 materials: Milk glass, white glass, or Mother of Pearl. Not all white glass is milk glass and vice versa. It's really hard to make a call without seeing it in person, but I believe we can get close after cleaning and other pics.

I'm going out on a limb and say I think it was hand-carved, perhaps in Germany. There is a possibility it is signed on the back of the glass portion.


Really neat find
Breezie

 

[HutSiteDigger]

Here is a milk glass button with white. I think breezie is got a point here with having too see it with your hands! After looking @ more milk glass buttons it seems most milk glass buttons are made more like a Jacksonian button! So there is a chance this isn't a milk glass button after all but it really does resemble milk glass.

 

[Bigcypresshunter]

Right now, I'm thinking it could be 1 of 3 materials: Milk glass, white glass, or Mother of Pearl. Not all white glass is milk glass and vice versa.
Really neat find
Breezie

Good to know. The thought of white coral also crossed my mind. Is there any easy sure way that you use to differentiate between milk glass and white glass or do you just go by experience and feel? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milk_glass



http://www.ehow.com/how_5044204_tell-glass-regular-white-glass.html

http://www.ebay.com/gds/When-Is-White-Glass-Not-Called-Milk-Glass/10000000001454111/g.html

 

[Bigcypresshunter]

Here is a milk glass button with white. I think breezie is got a point here with having too see it with your hands! After looking @ more milk glass buttons it seems most milk glass buttons are made more like a Jacksonian button! So there is a chance this isn't a milk glass button after all but it really does resemble milk glass.

Thats a very nice similar example Hut with the same brass ring. Can you post the link? Is there a picture of the back? Is it a steel or tin back?

 

[myrtlebeach]

Here are a couple of other pictures. I did try cleaning it like you suggested. It has "cracks" all through it. It feels like glass but I imagine if it was glass and cracked like that it would fall apart... It's interesting and I would definitely like to find out where it was made and when. Thanks

 

[surf]

Hey myrtlebeach,

Nice job on the cleaning. This is a very fascinating piece. I've been learning lots of non-germane stuff trying to find the origins of your button.

Tell me, please, how many square nodules comprise the outer circle? That is assuming that they are, indeed, square nodules...

Here's a "black glass" button, with far less symbology:

Antique Black Glass Button w Dusty Blue Luster 7 8" Fancy Center Pentagon 1906 | eBay

 

[Breezie]

After looking at the cleaned photos, we can rule out Mother of Pearl. As stated earlier, it's really hard to tell 'what' type of glass it is, but I'm going with milk glass. Actually, the kind of glass is not that important. What is important is the fact it is an antique hand carved glass button.

I don't give advice on what people should do with their finds, but if it were mine, I'd be awfully tempted to remove the 'shot' rusted back area leaving the brass ring and face. That way, you could see if it were signed/maker's mark, plus you've removed the rot.

Please don't do this unless your feelings are the same, and unless the back is beyond all reasonable repair. If the back is left untreated, the rust will continue to corrode and eventually the back will fall off.

Thanks for posting the new pics.

Breezie

 

[HutSiteDigger]

Myrtle- Milk glass is pretty strong glass. Even if cracked it is not gonna bust up like regular glass. Breezie is got very good ideas!