I have considered carrying but don't at this time. Personally, I would be more likely to carry in town where there are more people than in the woods.
Those of you who carry in the woods, why do you carry there? There shouldn't be any potential human threats there (if you're deep enough in the woods). I can understand why you would want to protect yourself against animal attacks. I'm not disagreeing with your choice, I just want to understand it.
I'll answer your question with my opinion...
Most violent crime attacks don't occur with 1,000 witness around. Most occur with little to know witnesses around. City or country, doesn't matter. Most criminals do not want to be caught immediately.
For instance, last few summers I hunted some old decayed parks/schools in Flint with a few buddies. I was packin', the 2 older gents with me didn't. There was literally NOBODY around. I'm talking 100 houses within eyesight of this Flint school...maybe 3 were lived in. Like 2 streets you could make a getaway on. All the other streets were piled so high with trash, couches, mattresses, garbagem etc, you could not possibly drive a car down it. Burned out houses, etc. Anyway, my buddy said...why would you ever feel the need to carry around here? Theres hardly anyone around.
I told him...that's exactly why I'm carrying...no witnesses either. We are the perfect targets. 2 older guys and fat kid...nobody around to help us. Sure enough...around 2pm there were 2 younger males who walked down the street past us. Then 10 minutes later they came back and there were 4 of them. Then they came back another 15 minutes and there were 6-7 of them. I told my buddies...yeah its time to go. Each time they passed us, they had a few more guys and were walking closer to us.
Now, I have no idea if they were out to cause trouble or not...but I had no intentions of sticking around to find out. Its not worth it to get a few coins. That was the last time I went "beeping" in Flint.
I don't usually carry beeping when I'm in my hometown, small town areas, or buddies houses, but in Urban areas or out in the middle of nowhere...I always carry.
This is my theory...
In Urban areas, there are more POS people out there...the higher the population of an area...the higher probability you eventually cross paths with a few bad seeds.
In the middle of nowhere/little population...less chance of someone else being able to help me if I needed it.
Therefore, I'll choose to do what I can to be able to defend myself.
Hope that never happens, but if so...at least I'll stand a fighting chance.
DH24