I've always preferred "shot" bullets, which BOTH of yours are. The deformation around the nose of your other bullet is evidence of a ramrod pushing it down. Shot bullets have more of a story to tell! Dropped bullets re worth more . . . but they just fell out of a pouch somewhere. Shot bullets - who fired that thing? Under what circumstances? What did it hit? That could be an interesting . . . or a horrible tale. We need more pics of your other lead piece. It could be a carved bullet . . .