What's new

Kirks

Hellbilly

Full Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2024
Messages
221
Reaction score
1,096
Golden Thread
0
Lets see some Kirks. Ill start with this one. Found west central Fla. Just under 6"
 

Attachments

  • Gomer1.webp
    Gomer1.webp
    85.5 KB · Views: 266
Upvote 5
Should these remarks pertain to me, I would humbly suggest that a less combative stance would be more appropriate for a moderator. Disseminating information in a provocative manner, particularly when one's role is to facilitate rather than inflame discussion, raises questions about judgment. Cultivating greater impartiality and fairness would better support the moderating function. This understanding is not mine alone. This represents a coordinated effort by numerous diggers- collectors based in Central Florida and extending into South Georgia. I would reasonably conclude that such a comprehensive group of contributors cannot be wholly mistaken. Nevertheless, I would respectfully propose that the current methodology is
1790775591908.webp

1790775482185.webp

1790775510906.webp
Is it perhaps worth considering that this specimen may not align precisely with the established Kirk Serrated classification? Given its flower pot stem configuration and drooping barbs—characteristics that diverge from the expected straight shoulders and square stem—it similarly does not conform to the Newnan category below. As this point exhibits serration, it represents a transitional form. During the 600 to 800 year overlap period, it transitions from Kirk Serrated above to Newnan below. Upon careful examination of the point's description, it becomes evident that it fits neither category cleanly. This represents a subtype of Newnan designated as Newkirk. This observation resonates with others who have examined comparable specimens from Central Florida to South Georgia. Given that it clearly demonstrates characteristics of both point types—Kirk Serrated as well as Newnan—it does not fit neatly into either classification. This makes it a transitional point during the overlapping time period. Personally, I find myself less concerned with strict typological classifications. My focus tends toward workmanship quality and authenticity.
 
View attachment 2267157
View attachment 2267155
View attachment 2267156Is it perhaps worth considering that this specimen may not align precisely with the established Kirk Serrated classification? Given its flower pot stem configuration and drooping barbs—characteristics that diverge from the expected straight shoulders and square stem—it similarly does not conform to the Newnan category below. As this point exhibits serration, it represents a transitional form. During the 600 to 800 year overlap period, it transitions from Kirk Serrated above to Newnan below. Upon careful examination of the point's description, it becomes evident that it fits neither category cleanly. This represents a subtype of Newnan designated as Newkirk. This observation resonates with others who have examined comparable specimens from Central Florida to South Georgia. Given that it clearly demonstrates characteristics of both point types—Kirk Serrated as well as Newnan—it does not fit neatly into either classification. This makes it a transitional point during the overlapping time period. Personally, I find myself less concerned with strict typological classifications. My focus tends toward workmanship quality and authenticity.
I will humbly disagree with your analysis of the Kirk serrated morphing into a Newnan. Newnan points did extend out to various styles still within the cluster of its type, such as Hillsborough, Orange, Lochloossa. Newnan stayed inside of Florida for the most part with a few being found in Georgia and Alabama. Kirks are much older and much more widespread across the Eastern seaboard & mid western states and seem to have been associated with notched type points of similar style & age. You can petition state archeologists with your findings and see if they agree and may be willing to acknowledge the "Newkirk" in a professional paper signed by several people who are qualified to accept your findings as legitimate.
 
Posts deleted.....

Some seem to just refuse to listen when rules are explained, and or read our rules even after requests to do so.

It violates our rules to lecture or challenge moderation or administration of Treasurenet in open forums, that is handled through a PM to a moderator.

Muki is on timeout.
 
You cant just make up your own name and call it a new style.
It pays to do a little research before you close your mind to what's already happened when you aren't looking or we're not there when it happened.

Case in point:

Transitional forms between earlier Kirk types and later Newnan styles exist, with some specimens displaying mixed characteristics during the 600-800 year overlap period. These transitional points illustrate the gradual evolution of styles in this classification.

Transition from Kirk Serrated to Newnan
Overview of the Transition
The Kirk Serrated point is recognized as a transitional form between earlier Kirk types and later styles, particularly the Newnan. This transition occurred over a significant period, characterized by overlapping features between the two types.

Characteristics of the Transition
Overlap Period: The transition from Kirk Serrated to Newnan spans approximately 600 to 800 years.
Mixed Features: Some specimens exhibit characteristics of both Kirk Serrated and Newnan, indicating a gradual evolution rather than a sudden change.

Conclusion
The transition from Kirk Serrated to Newnan reflects a gradual evolution in design and function, with evidence of mixed characteristics in some artifacts. This indicates a complex relationship between these two types over time.

Archaeological evidence indicates that both Kirk Serrated and Newnan points were used during overlapping time periods, specifically the Early to Middle Archaic period. This suggests a continuity and evolution in projectile point technology within the same cultural contexts.

The point type that shows a transition between Kirk Serrated and Newnan is referred to as Newkirk. This subtype exhibits characteristics of both point types and represents a transitional form during their overlapping period.

Transitional Point Type
The point type that shows a transition between Kirk Serrated and Newnan is known as Newkirk.

Characteristics of Newkirk Points
Newkirk points exhibit features from both Kirk Serrated and Newnan types, making them unique transitional artifacts. Here are some defining attributes:

Context of Use
Newkirk points are significant as they represent a period of overlap between the Kirk Serrated and Newnan types, indicating that they were used by similar cultures during their respective time frames. This transitional form highlights the evolution of projectile points in the archaeological record.

The Newkirk point type is characterized by its triangular shape with a corner notch, typically medium to large in size (1.5 to 4 inches), and features a random flaking pattern. It often has a flattened to elliptical cross-section and may exhibit serrations on the blade.

Newkirk points are variations of Kirk points and are generally considered to be younger than Kirk Serrated points, which date back to the Early to Middle Archaic period. Newnan points, on the other hand, are also from the Mid Archaic period and are less widespread than Kirk points, indicating that while there may be some overlap in usage, they represent different cultural

Newkirk points are indeed variations of Kirk points, specifically associated with the Kirk cluster of projectile points, which includes several styles that are typically triangular and corner-notched. These points reflect the evolution and regional adaptations of the Kirk point types during the Early Archaic period.

Newkirk Points Overview
Newkirk points are indeed variations of Kirk points, which belong to the Kirk cluster of projectile points. This cluster includes several styles that are typically triangular and corner-notched.

Characteristics of Newkirk Points
Shape: Triangular with corner notches.
Edges: Serrated along the edges.
Base: Generally straight or slightly rounded.
Historical Context
Newkirk points reflect the evolution and regional adaptations of Kirk point types during the Early Archaic period. This period is characterized by significant advancements in tool-making techniques and the adaptation of tools to various environments.

Newkirk points and Kirk points were influenced by regional adaptations primarily due to the availability of local materials and environmental conditions. The Kirk points, for example, are associated with the Eastern Seaboard and Gulf Coastal regions, where the design evolved to suit the hunting practices and resources available in those areas.
 
Last edited:
Posts deleted.....

Some seem to just refuse to listen when rules are explained, and or read our rules even after requests to do so.

It violates our rules to lecture or challenge moderation or administration of Treasurenet in open forums, that is handled through a PM to a moderator.

Muki is on timeout.
There are those who tend to instigate harassment, pushing people towards being combative rather than receptive. Even though they were wrong from the start, this is when a proper apology is fitting. I posted the research for everyone, including those who only had the interest to act as keyboard warriors.
 
Last edited:
It pays to do a little research before you close your mind to what's already happened when you aren't looking or we're not there when it happened.

Case in point:

Transitional forms between earlier Kirk types and later Newnan styles exist, with some specimens displaying mixed characteristics during the 600-800 year overlap period. These transitional points illustrate the gradual evolution of styles in this classification.

Transition from Kirk Serrated to Newnan
Overview of the Transition
The Kirk Serrated point is recognized as a transitional form between earlier Kirk types and later styles, particularly the Newnan. This transition occurred over a significant period, characterized by overlapping features between the two types.

Characteristics of the Transition
Overlap Period: The transition from Kirk Serrated to Newnan spans approximately 600 to 800 years.
Mixed Features: Some specimens exhibit characteristics of both Kirk Serrated and Newnan, indicating a gradual evolution rather than a sudden change.

Conclusion
The transition from Kirk Serrated to Newnan reflects a gradual evolution in design and function, with evidence of mixed characteristics in some artifacts. This indicates a complex relationship between these two types over time.

Archaeological evidence indicates that both Kirk Serrated and Newnan points were used during overlapping time periods, specifically the Early to Middle Archaic period. This suggests a continuity and evolution in projectile point technology within the same cultural contexts.

The point type that shows a transition between Kirk Serrated and Newnan is referred to as Newkirk. This subtype exhibits characteristics of both point types and represents a transitional form during their overlapping period.

Transitional Point Type
The point type that shows a transition between Kirk Serrated and Newnan is known as Newkirk.

Characteristics of Newkirk Points
Newkirk points exhibit features from both Kirk Serrated and Newnan types, making them unique transitional artifacts. Here are some defining attributes:

Context of Use
Newkirk points are significant as they represent a period of overlap between the Kirk Serrated and Newnan types, indicating that they were used by similar cultures during their respective time frames. This transitional form highlights the evolution of projectile points in the archaeological record.

The Newkirk point type is characterized by its triangular shape with a corner notch, typically medium to large in size (1.5 to 4 inches), and features a random flaking pattern. It often has a flattened to elliptical cross-section and may exhibit serrations on the blade.

Newkirk points are variations of Kirk points and are generally considered to be younger than Kirk Serrated points, which date back to the Early to Middle Archaic period. Newnan points, on the other hand, are also from the Mid Archaic period and are less widespread than Kirk points, indicating that while there may be some overlap in usage, they represent different cultural

Newkirk points are indeed variations of Kirk points, specifically associated with the Kirk cluster of projectile points, which includes several styles that are typically triangular and corner-notched. These points reflect the evolution and regional adaptations of the Kirk point types during the Early Archaic period.

Newkirk Points Overview
Newkirk points are indeed variations of Kirk points, which belong to the Kirk cluster of projectile points. This cluster includes several styles that are typically triangular and corner-notched.

Characteristics of Newkirk Points
Shape: Triangular with corner notches.
Edges: Serrated along the edges.
Base: Generally straight or slightly rounded.
Historical Context
Newkirk points reflect the evolution and regional adaptations of Kirk point types during the Early Archaic period. This period is characterized by significant advancements in tool-making techniques and the adaptation of tools to various environments.

Newkirk points and Kirk points were influenced by regional adaptations primarily due to the availability of local materials and environmental conditions. The Kirk points, for example, are associated with the Eastern Seaboard and Gulf Coastal regions, where the design evolved to suit the hunting practices and resources available in those areas.
OK, Say I buy this. can you show us were the word "NEWKIRK" is used by any archaeology papers or point type books? I have several books on point types and have never seen any point typed as such. I also have a CN Kirk that some say is a Bolen so would this be a Kirklen or NEWBOLEN . I will find a pic for your judgement.
 

Attachments

  • CN Kirk.webp
    CN Kirk.webp
    53 KB · Views: 10
Newnans and Kirks are not related, one did not morph into another. Kirks are much older, at least 3000 years than Newnan points. Kirks are notched usually and are found from Florida to the upper Mid West & along the Eastern Seaboard. Newnans are stemmed and almost exclusively a Florida point with a few found in Southern Georgia and Eastern Alabama. There are no "Newkirks" and while you may wish there to be or are just a troll having fun no one on this site is buying in.
 
Newnans and Kirks are not related, one did not morph into another. Kirks are much older, at least 3000 years than Newnan points. Kirks are notched usually and are found from Florida to the upper Mid West & along the Eastern Seaboard. Newnans are stemmed and almost exclusively a Florida point with a few found in Southern Georgia and Eastern Alabama. There are no "Newkirks" and while you may wish there to be or are just a troll having fun no one on this site is buying in.
A sequence of radiocarbon-dated MA sites is presented in
Figure 2 and Table 1, and with this, we can better discuss their
associated point types (Figures 1b and 2). The age estimate
at Windover on human bone of 8120 + 70 B.P. (9250 - 8990
cal B.P.) is the next earliest age, after the last of the Bolen
ages, representing clear evidence for the presence of people
and what we consider the earliest of MA sites2. Figure 2 shows
that the Windover radiocarbon samples range over more than
a thousand years without other sites being represented. The
youngest age at Windover, again on human bone, is 6990 +
70 B.P. (7930 - 7740 cal B.P.). A stake associated with one of
the burials from the slough at Little Salt Springs, the Hazeltine
site, returned a slightly later age of 6830 + 155 B.P. (7840
- 7520 cal B.P.), and West Williams produced a single age
below a zone of MA artifacts of 6810 + 40 B.P (7675 - 7610
cal B.P.) (Austin et al. 2004; Clausen et al. 1979). At Bay West
three stakes average 6675 + 40 (7585 - 7505 cal B.P.), and
at Republic Groves ages range from 6520 + 65 to 5745 + 65
B.P. (7510 - 7330 and 6640 - 6480 cal B.P.) (Beriault et al.
1981; Wharton et al. 1981). Windover, Hazeltine, Bay West,
and Republic Groves are each pond/peat burial cemeteries
that have produced impressive numbers of preserved human
remains associated with artifacts of antler, bone, wood, fabric,
atlatl parts, and, occasionally, stone projectile points (Beriault
1981; Byrd 2011; Carr and Jones 1981; Doran 2002 Wharton
et al. 1981).
Projectile points from Windover include three thick,
rectangular based “Kirk Serrated” specimens (Dickel
2002:117-118), two of which were associated with burials.
Bay West burials also produced three points designated as
FAS (Levy rectangular based) by Beriault et al. (1981), along
with a round-based Newnan (not associated with any burials).
All three points at Bay West were wide with respect to length
(i.e., stubby), in contrast to the longer examples at Windover.
Beriault et al. (1981) reported that some of the points were heat
treated. At West Williams, two small rectangular-based points,
found below the radiocarbon age of 6810 + 40 B.P. (7675 - 7610
cal B.P.) mentioned above, were designated “Kirk Serrated”
(Austin et al. 2004). Similar points were designated Wacissa
by Tesar (1994) at the Johnson Sand Pit, but no radiocarbon
or stratigraphic information exists for this site. The burials
from Republic Groves produced a large inventory of chipped
stone items including round-based Putman FAS points, but
none from radiometrically-dated contexts. At Jeannie’s Better
Back, a single Kirk Serrated point was designated in the MA
assemblage, but, again, no radiocarbon date (Austin and
Mitchell 1999). Likewise, one specimen was designated as
Kirk Serrated from the upper MA levels at Wakulla Springs
(Tesar and Jones 2004), and two were culled from the Johnson
Sand Pit collection (Tesar 1994). We discuss these specimens
again below.
Table 1 and Figure 2 show that sites producing
radiocarbon ages later than 6500 B.P. (~ 7430 cal B.P.) are
more frequent, including Hontoon Dead Creek, Horr’s Island,
Live Oak Mound, Lake Monroe, Salt Springs, and Ussepa
Island (Austin et al. 2004; Deming 2000; Marquardt 1992;
O’Donoughue et al. 2011; Randall and Sassaman 2005; Russo
et al. 1991; Sassaman 2003). There are several MA sites with
ages around 6000 B.P. (~ 6840 cal B.P.); these are the result of
work along the middle St Johns River by the National Parks
Service and the Laboratory of Southeastern Archaeology at
the University of Florida. Newnan projectile points occur with
these later sites, as do other FAS types.
Gauthier, Diamond Dairy, and Johnson Lake are sites
with FAS points from excavated contexts. Unfortunately,
they are without radiocarbon control or stratigraphic evidence
for PI or EA presence that would contribute to the sense of
cultural continuity between earlier and later times. Johnson
Sand Pit also is without stratigraphic or radiocarbon control.
Paradise Park and Harney Flats produced FAS and Newnan
points in upper stratigraphic levels, including both round- and
rectangular-based Putnam and Levy varieties, and both sites
produced evidence for a lacuna between earlier PI-EA artifacts
and later MA assemblages, as described in more detail below
(Daniel and Wisenbaker 1987; Neil 1958:38). Unfortunately,
there are no radiocarbon controls for either of these important
archaeological sites.
Radiocarbon Data Gap
In addition to chronological control for the sites and
artifacts already discussed, frequency distributions of the
number of radiocarbon ages can be and have been used as
proxies for population dynamics over the Holocene epoch.
Based on the theory that more people produce more sites
from which archaeologists take more radiocarbon samples; or,
likewise, that fewer people, produce fewer sites, and therefore
fewer samples are taken by archaeologists (e.g., Breschini et
al. 1988; Berry and Berry 1986; Faught 2008; Steele 2010).
Of course there are preservation and sampling biases involved,
and other data need to be taken into account for theorizing, but
we consider the current sample to be at the least sufcient for
preliminary analysis.
The Dasovich and Doran (2011) compilation includes
1254 radiocarbon ages, ranging from late Pleistocene to historic
time (Dasovich 1996). From this sample we culled 143 ages
older than 5000 B.P. from 27 sites. We added 78 radiocarbon
ages from 12 sites not included in their sample. This results in
a collection of 221 radiocarbon ages older than 5000 B.P. from
39 Florida sites. These ages, and their standard deviations,, are
presented in Appendix I and illustrated in Figure 2 (frequency
distribution of the ages to the left, calibrated probability curves
to the upper right, and sites discussed in the text are indicated).
Radiocarbon ages indicating human behavior, human
presence, or those made on skeletal remains are bolded
(n=124), while ages with a standard deviation of more than
200 years, or those downgraded for other reasons, particularly
environmental samples such as peat or wood not indicating
human presence, are shown in gray (n=97)3. Most sites are
represented by single ages, but Page/Ladson (n=43), Warm
Mineral Springs (n=30), Little Salt Springs (n=20), Windover
(n=13), J&J Hunt (n=10), Lake Monroe (n=8), Salt Springs
(n=8), Tick Island (n=8), Bay West (n=7), Groves Orange
Midden (n=7), Hontoon Dead Creek (n=7), Mouth of Silver
 
OK, Say I buy this. can you show us were the word "NEWKIRK" is used by any archaeology papers or point type books? I have several books on point types and have never seen any point typed as such. I also have a CN Kirk that some say is a Bolen so would this be a Kirklen or NEWBOLEN . I will find a pic for your judgement.
This type Has been called NewKirk due to its Kirk and Newnan characteristics, most likely a transitional form, albeit rare in occurrence.Also called Fullmer in the Legends In Stone Archaic Stemmed Edition after the name of a finder that found a spot with several classic examples.
 
You are the only person who I've ever heard say that people said there were no Paleo artifacts in Florida. They have been finding Paleo and Trans Paleo artifacts in Florida from early on. Simpson, Wheeler, Clovis, Dalton, Suwanee, etc.
Oh boy. Some people will stretch things just to provoke an argument without reading the full content. Please give credit where credit is due. Ben Waller shared this with me directly while we were at his house in Silver Spring, Florida

Ripley Pierce Bullen who was Curator Emeritus at the Florida Museum of Natural History at the University of Florida said that to Ben Waller back in 1950's when Ben found a cache or Clovis points embedded in a Mastodon in the Silver River which he quickly covered back up to preserve it for Ripley Bullen who collected information about Florida projectile points to come and study the find after multiple phone calls insisting that he come document the discovery over a long course of time Bullen finally told Ben that he was not coming to look at it because there was no Paleo point in Florida

Ripley P. Bullen, past Florida Museum curator of Florida Archaeology, collected information about Florida projectile points from both avocational and professional archaeologists for decades.

Ripley P. Bullen, past Florida Museum curator of Florida Archaeology, collected information about Florida projectile points from both avocational and professional archaeologists for decades.

Timeline:​

  • 1957 – Museum records suggest this is when Bullen first gathered data for the projectile point classification.
  • 1967 – Bullen presented first rendition of projectile point typology at a Florida Anthropological Society meeting.
  • 1968 – First edition of the projectile point guide describing 43 types was published by the Florida State Museum (now Florida Museum of Natural History).
  • 1975 – Second edition, basically a revision of original types and chronological distinctions as well as additions depicting 54 types was published by Kendall Books™.
  • 2004 – First web page on Bullen projectile point type collection provides inventory and history by Jerald T. Milanich, Curator in Archaeology 1975-2007, now Curator Emeritus (How Bullen created his projectile point classification guide).
  • 2005 – Isolated Finds Policy in Florida was discussed and discontinued. It is against the law for anyone to collect or remove artifacts from state or federal lands including underwater sites. For more information, visit Florida Division of Historic Resources.
  • 2012 – Revised Bullen projectile point type collection expanded to
    include galleries for each type and point in the collection.
 
Last edited:

The three Kirk Stemmed points mentioned above were found at this site alongside Newnan artifacts. Two were associated with burials, offering archaeological evidence that dates back 50 years. Archaeological records show that the Kirk Corner Notch was most closely associated with the Bolen Beveled, followed by the Kirk Serrated and then the rectangular based “Kirk Serrated”, as it developed into the Newnan culture. These associations are documented in detail above. The full document presents a fascinating account of Florida’s history from the Paleo period through the Middle Archaic. Interested readers can download the PDF.

 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest Discussions

Back
Top Bottom