Newnans and Kirks are not related, one did not morph into another. Kirks are much older, at least 3000 years than Newnan points. Kirks are notched usually and are found from Florida to the upper Mid West & along the Eastern Seaboard. Newnans are stemmed and almost exclusively a Florida point with a few found in Southern Georgia and Eastern Alabama. There are no "Newkirks" and while you may wish there to be or are just a troll having fun no one on this site is buying in.
A sequence of radiocarbon-dated MA sites is presented in
Figure 2 and Table 1, and with this, we can better discuss their
associated point types (Figures 1b and 2). The age estimate
at Windover on human bone of 8120 + 70 B.P. (9250 - 8990
cal B.P.) is the next earliest age, after the last of the Bolen
ages, representing clear evidence for the presence of people
and what we consider the earliest of MA sites2. Figure 2 shows
that the Windover radiocarbon samples range over more than
a thousand years without other sites being represented. The
youngest age at Windover, again on human bone, is 6990 +
70 B.P. (7930 - 7740 cal B.P.). A stake associated with one of
the burials from the slough at Little Salt Springs, the Hazeltine
site, returned a slightly later age of 6830 + 155 B.P. (7840
- 7520 cal B.P.), and West Williams produced a single age
below a zone of MA artifacts of 6810 + 40 B.P (7675 - 7610
cal B.P.) (Austin et al. 2004; Clausen et al. 1979). At Bay West
three stakes average 6675 + 40 (7585 - 7505 cal B.P.), and
at Republic Groves ages range from 6520 + 65 to 5745 + 65
B.P. (7510 - 7330 and 6640 - 6480 cal B.P.) (Beriault et al.
1981; Wharton et al. 1981). Windover, Hazeltine, Bay West,
and Republic Groves are each pond/peat burial cemeteries
that have produced impressive numbers of preserved human
remains associated with artifacts of antler, bone, wood, fabric,
atlatl parts, and, occasionally, stone projectile points (Beriault
1981; Byrd 2011; Carr and Jones 1981; Doran 2002 Wharton
et al. 1981).
Projectile points from Windover include three thick,
rectangular based “Kirk Serrated” specimens (Dickel
2002:117-118), two of which were associated with burials.
Bay West burials also produced three points designated as
FAS (Levy rectangular based) by Beriault et al. (1981), along
with a round-based Newnan (not associated with any burials).
All three points at Bay West were wide with respect to length
(i.e., stubby), in contrast to the longer examples at Windover.
Beriault et al. (1981) reported that some of the points were heat
treated. At West Williams, two small rectangular-based points,
found below the radiocarbon age of 6810 + 40 B.P. (7675 - 7610
cal B.P.) mentioned above, were designated “Kirk Serrated”
(Austin et al. 2004). Similar points were designated Wacissa
by Tesar (1994) at the Johnson Sand Pit, but no radiocarbon
or stratigraphic information exists for this site. The burials
from Republic Groves produced a large inventory of chipped
stone items including round-based Putman FAS points, but
none from radiometrically-dated contexts. At Jeannie’s Better
Back, a single Kirk Serrated point was designated in the MA
assemblage, but, again, no radiocarbon date (Austin and
Mitchell 1999). Likewise, one specimen was designated as
Kirk Serrated from the upper MA levels at Wakulla Springs
(Tesar and Jones 2004), and two were culled from the Johnson
Sand Pit collection (Tesar 1994). We discuss these specimens
again below.
Table 1 and Figure 2 show that sites producing
radiocarbon ages later than 6500 B.P. (~ 7430 cal B.P.) are
more frequent, including Hontoon Dead Creek, Horr’s Island,
Live Oak Mound, Lake Monroe, Salt Springs, and Ussepa
Island (Austin et al. 2004; Deming 2000; Marquardt 1992;
O’Donoughue et al. 2011; Randall and Sassaman 2005; Russo
et al. 1991; Sassaman 2003). There are several MA sites with
ages around 6000 B.P. (~ 6840 cal B.P.); these are the result of
work along the middle St Johns River by the National Parks
Service and the Laboratory of Southeastern Archaeology at
the University of Florida. Newnan projectile points occur with
these later sites, as do other FAS types.
Gauthier, Diamond Dairy, and Johnson Lake are sites
with FAS points from excavated contexts. Unfortunately,
they are without radiocarbon control or stratigraphic evidence
for PI or EA presence that would contribute to the sense of
cultural continuity between earlier and later times. Johnson
Sand Pit also is without stratigraphic or radiocarbon control.
Paradise Park and Harney Flats produced FAS and Newnan
points in upper stratigraphic levels, including both round- and
rectangular-based Putnam and Levy varieties, and both sites
produced evidence for a lacuna between earlier PI-EA artifacts
and later MA assemblages, as described in more detail below
(Daniel and Wisenbaker 1987; Neil 1958:38). Unfortunately,
there are no radiocarbon controls for either of these important
archaeological sites.
Radiocarbon Data Gap
In addition to chronological control for the sites and
artifacts already discussed, frequency distributions of the
number of radiocarbon ages can be and have been used as
proxies for population dynamics over the Holocene epoch.
Based on the theory that more people produce more sites
from which archaeologists take more radiocarbon samples; or,
likewise, that fewer people, produce fewer sites, and therefore
fewer samples are taken by archaeologists (e.g., Breschini et
al. 1988; Berry and Berry 1986; Faught 2008; Steele 2010).
Of course there are preservation and sampling biases involved,
and other data need to be taken into account for theorizing, but
we consider the current sample to be at the least sufcient for
preliminary analysis.
The Dasovich and Doran (2011) compilation includes
1254 radiocarbon ages, ranging from late Pleistocene to historic
time (Dasovich 1996). From this sample we culled 143 ages
older than 5000 B.P. from 27 sites. We added 78 radiocarbon
ages from 12 sites not included in their sample. This results in
a collection of 221 radiocarbon ages older than 5000 B.P. from
39 Florida sites. These ages, and their standard deviations,, are
presented in Appendix I and illustrated in Figure 2 (frequency
distribution of the ages to the left, calibrated probability curves
to the upper right, and sites discussed in the text are indicated).
Radiocarbon ages indicating human behavior, human
presence, or those made on skeletal remains are bolded
(n=124), while ages with a standard deviation of more than
200 years, or those downgraded for other reasons, particularly
environmental samples such as peat or wood not indicating
human presence, are shown in gray (n=97)3. Most sites are
represented by single ages, but Page/Ladson (n=43), Warm
Mineral Springs (n=30), Little Salt Springs (n=20), Windover
(n=13), J&J Hunt (n=10), Lake Monroe (n=8), Salt Springs
(n=8), Tick Island (n=8), Bay West (n=7), Groves Orange
Midden (n=7), Hontoon Dead Creek (n=7), Mouth of Silver