What's new

Mystery coin turns out to be an OLDIE!!!

Johnny Ringo Silver

Hero Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2007
Messages
885
Reaction score
7
Golden Thread
0
Location
KANSAS
Detector(s) used
Minelab SE and Sunray probe
A week ago, I was hunting a field where a one room school house once stood. I had pulled up 5 or 6 indians and a V-nickel along with a 1919 mercury dime. I was totally happy with what I had found because I consider finding any coins at an old one room pretty good.
Well, I got a good dime signal at about 5in or so and I dug a 6in plug and popped it out. As the full plug turned over, a piece of dirt the size of a golf ball fell off the bottom. I scanned the hole with the trusty sunray and then the full plug with neither giving me a response.
I then swung the sunray over that little clump of dirt that fell from the bottom and there she was. All of the other coins from this site were 1901 to 1920's and thats it so I figured the silver dime within the plug would be a late barber or early merc. I then had an idea.....
Our club meeting was the next weekend "This last sunday" and I have always wanted to keep a silver in a plug to take to the club meeting and have one of our members kids open it up to see what year it was. So since the silver dime was in this clump of dirt and I had a good idea what age it was going to be I figured this was as good a time as any. I posted the story on our clubs website and offered up a contest to see who could guess the closest to the correct year and the winner would recieve a walking liberty half from me.
The waiting was killing me and I am suprised that I lasted the whole week without breaking it open. You could just barely see the reeds peeking out one side of the dirt and it was teasing me. At our meeting/hunt I asked one of our youngest members "the daughter of another member" to open it up and see what it was. After sitting in my garage for a week, the dirt had dried up totally and when she put the squeeze to it the ball of dirt just crumbled to dust revealing a very worn out silver coin that was still too dirty to easily ID. Someone brought over a bottle of water and I washed the coin off revealing what we were all anxious to know. This is when it just got totally awesome!!! I was looking down at a SEATED DIME with arrows and a real faint date!!!! How about that!!!!! I finally brought in a silver to open in front of the whole club and it turns out to be a seated !!! After close inspection the dime turns out to be an 1853 variety 3 I believe. I had to go back and change the date for oldest coin found this month scratching out my 1895 indian that I had already recorded.
The closest guess was 1901 and he got his walker. Everyone was thrilled to see the seated come out of the plug.
Memories made one plug at a time!!! 8)
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1427.webp
    IMG_1427.webp
    67.3 KB · Views: 957
  • IMG_1444.webp
    IMG_1444.webp
    41.4 KB · Views: 955
  • IMG_1445.webp
    IMG_1445.webp
    37.3 KB · Views: 949
Upvote 0
What an exciting story, Johnny!! :thumbsup: Yeah, I'm not sure if I could hold out so long just looking at that reeded edge all week. I would have busted it open. :wink:

Sometimes you wonder how you can unearth a coin some 50 years older than the average years of coins you're finding at a certain site, but then I begin to realize that I still pull out 60's memorials from my pocket change from time to time, and looking at the wear on your coin, it looks like it was in circulation for a while.

Very Cool!! :thumbsup:

HH,
CAPTN SE
Dan
 
Holy (Word would be deleted) Johnny! That is a cool story man. Just looking at the reeded edge's condition, I would've placed my money on it being a merc! Those edges are still in great shape! I find mercs with edges that don't exist.........and what edges on any of the barber dimes I've found? None existent. Matter of fact, they are so thin and worn you could possibly get a silver cut from them! Congrats on that seated find buddy.
 
Supper story, must have been a strong will power to resist opening up the dirt clot. Supper silver find.... :wav: :wav: :wav: :wav: :wav:
 
How's that for suspense?!

Nice one. :thumbsup:


You know, the longer you wait to see what it is after it's dug--the older it gets, right?

;D


Great Job!


-Buck
 
Tha's a great story of the plug JRS....I've heard of people taking "Ice" plug's and thawing them out in the winter time which I'm definetley gonna try this year ;D Awesome outcome and awesome way of going about it.Nice Job!!!!
 
WTG on the seated Johnny..and what a cool thing you did making a contest out of it..sounds like you all had a great time. Nice job!

Nat
 
civilman1 said:
Tha's a great story of the plug JRS....I've heard of people taking "Ice" plug's and thawing them out in the winter time which I'm definetley gonna try this year ;D Awesome outcome and awesome way of going about it.Nice Job!!!!

We've done it--carried home 30 lbs of dirt in a sack to thaw and find the goodies. :thumbsup: It's almost enjoying the fun of digging them up twice!


-Buckles
 
Awesome Find !!! You made some kids day and gave him something he will remember forever. :thumbsup:
 
That was a great story. There would be no way I could have waited to see what I had. Congratulations!!! :wav: :occasion18: :hello2: :headbang: :wav:
 
Great story! Congrats on the superb find! ;D

Sounds like you have a good club going there, and what a great idea to make the meeting fun! :thumbsup:
 
New contest, Who was more excited when they saw the mystery coin?You ,the kid , or the winner? Great idea and outcome!
 
awesome story and find :thumbsup:
 
Great story Johnny! Love seeing that silver peaking out of the plug...
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom