Roadhse2
Sr. Member
- Joined
- Mar 15, 2015
- Messages
- 376
- Reaction score
- 366
- Golden Thread
- 0
- Primary Interest:
- All Treasure Hunting
"10 vessels premised traveling from Cyprus to La Rochelle/ Vessels leaving Cyprus is documented, number is premised by amount of cargo hauled"
First thing you premise is based on what? What tonnage were each one of these ships? That determines amount of cargo they can carry, without knowing that, you cannot premise how many ships at all. Of course ships left Cyprus, it was a port city. Do you have the port/ship logs showing ships and destination? Ships don't just pick up cargo, or anything else and disappear into the night with no port records.
"Join with maybe 8 other ships at La Rochelle/ Having vessels based in La Rochelle is documented, number is premised based on wine trade"
Same as above....
"All 18 leave La Rochelle in early September 1307/ All the vessels in the harbor did leave and they all disappeared"
Here you try to change your unqualified premise into a fact, the number of ships, and that they "did leave" Once again with nothing to back that up....
"premise three leaving Scotland for North America in spring of 1308"
Why not 1? Why not 4? Once again, no information, just made up crap
You want to talk disinformation...your whole theory is based on it.
First thing you premise is based on what? What tonnage were each one of these ships? That determines amount of cargo they can carry, without knowing that, you cannot premise how many ships at all. Of course ships left Cyprus, it was a port city. Do you have the port/ship logs showing ships and destination? Ships don't just pick up cargo, or anything else and disappear into the night with no port records.
"Join with maybe 8 other ships at La Rochelle/ Having vessels based in La Rochelle is documented, number is premised based on wine trade"
Same as above....
"All 18 leave La Rochelle in early September 1307/ All the vessels in the harbor did leave and they all disappeared"
Here you try to change your unqualified premise into a fact, the number of ships, and that they "did leave" Once again with nothing to back that up....
"premise three leaving Scotland for North America in spring of 1308"
Why not 1? Why not 4? Once again, no information, just made up crap
You want to talk disinformation...your whole theory is based on it.
Last edited: