Dug My BEST in 20 Years Today

BuckleBoy

Platinum Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2006
Messages
18,132
Reaction score
9,701
Golden Thread
4
Location
Moonlight and Magnolias
🥇 Banner finds
4
🏆 Honorable Mentions:
2
Detector(s) used
Fisher F75, Whites DualField PI, Fisher 1266-X and Tesoro Silver uMax
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
UPDATE IN REPLY #102! It appears that the example of the PB countermark on my coin was UNIQUE as of 2003--hoping for more information on whether any have been recovered since!

Hello All,

I am still shaking from the find I just made, even though some hours have passed. I had metal detecting dreams last night. Was surprised I didn't wake to find a dig hole in my mattress! :D

Went out with Diggergirl to a site where she wanted to dig an old bottle trash pit. I got that excavation process started with her, and left her there happily recovering bottles.

HPIM4169.webp

But the cane fields were calling me, and I just couldn't wait to get the F75 fired up and get in there. I didn't have high hopes, because the signs were turn-of-the-century, which is usually a bust down here in South Louisiana, due to the economic destruction of the civil war and Reconstruction period, followed immediately by the collapse of the depression. Plus, I really prefer CW-era and earlier finds. Just more history there, and more interest to me.

At any rate, I got going and to my surprise dug a couple Civil War bullets right off (dopped burnside and a .69 cal round ball). Picked up an 1890 IH right on top of the ground that beeped at me as I walked by. But I wasn't prepared for what I dug next! It was a quarter of an 8Reales. I had wanted a Big 8 forever, and had seen Hill Billy dig FOUR of them in Old Kentucky, and my digging buddy down here dug one last year! While I was really happy for them, I wanted one for the collection.

Well...it gets better! The cut coin has the coveted Planter's Bank New Orleans counterstamp! One of these was featured in Western & Eastern Treasures Magazine Best Finds issue this year, and they normally sell for $4,000-$6,000.00! An especially nice condition counterstamp of the same type recently sold for over $9,000: http://legacy.stacks.com/Lot/ItemDetail/4183

Enjoy the video and photos. I have a photo below of the Western & Eastern write-up in the Best Finds issue, but information on this rare counterstamp is readily available online as well.



Parts of three solid silver spoons:

HPIM4179.webpHPIM4177.webpHPIM4178.webp

1890 IH was a nice surprise:

HPIM4180.webpHPIM4181.webp

Nice 1913 Barber Dime :)

HPIM4175.webpHPIM4176.webp

And the cut 8Reales:

HPIM4173.webpHPIM4174.webp

HPIM4172.webp

The "PB" stamp is different on the one I dug than any others I've seen (an oval on mine vs a circle with chain border on the others). Wonder if that's a new variety of the counterstamp?

All the digs, not including the brass crappe (recycling!) and bucket of scrap iron. :D

HPIM4182.webp

It's nice to finally hit a BIG find. I knew one of us would dig one sooner or later. Even though I still want to dig a gold coin, IMO this is better than a gold coin, not only in terms of value, but also in history.

Best Wishes,


Buck
 

Last edited:
Upvote 70
Outstanding! Dug lots of cut 2 reales but only 1 cut 8 reale and it was an eighth of the coin............ and none were counter stamped. Although mine were definitely lost in 1781 by French soldiers so they couldn't have been. My banner vote is in! Congratulations on a great discovery!!! Devonrex
 

Last edited:
Very cool piece, never seen one - big congrats!

How much do you think it might be worth (shame the countermarked eagle is faint)?

I would guess $3,000-$4,000.
 

Congrats BB! What a find! I love to see these spanish silvers on here, but you got the icing on the cake! What i told you about the effort you put into your hunts.... :notworthy:

You were right! Cheers,

BB
 

Very cool piece, never seen one - big congrats!

How much do you think it might be worth (shame the countermarked eagle is faint)?

Buckleboy's find is a super find, no doubt about that. I never heard of this counterstamp and after doing some research, wow, it is a goodie There was one sold at auction (Heritage) for over 6 grand, but the counterstamp was in superb condition, but still, with the rarity I am sure it would be a nice amount if ever sold.
 

That is one awesome find. I am so happy for you because you work hard at researching and digging. You deserve a great find.
Congrats
Doug
 

That is one awesome find. I am so happy for you because you work hard at researching and digging. You deserve a great find.
Congrats
Doug

Well, you're a tough act to follow, Mr. CSA and Texas Republic button! :D
 

Buckleboy's find is a super find, no doubt about that. I never heard of this counterstamp and after doing some research, wow, it is a goodie There was one sold at auction (Heritage) for over 6 grand, but the counterstamp was in superb condition, but still, with the rarity I am sure it would be a nice amount if ever sold.

Thanks so much for your reply, Don. It's so nice to get a great find. I've gotten nice bits from time to time, but nothing ever in this league.

Cheers,

Buckles
 

SUPER COOL FIND!!

my banner vote is in!!
 

Congrats on your 4th Banner BB!!! You work very hard for the relics and coins you recover. Members of Tnet have no idea of the rigors of hunting in the LA summer. As I have stated many times, the Canefield Bandits deserve every coin & relic they recover. HH, Q.
 

Congratulations! I always know when I see you posting something, it's gonna be good.
 

Last edited:
Congrats BuckleBoy!
 

Hey Buckles, I know I already posted on your GREAT find, but you had not made the BANNER then, so I had to post again to say CONGRATULATIONS on making a well deserved BANNER!!! :) Breezie
 

Hard to top this. Pretty freakin' amazing! Congrats on the banner!!!
 

Brilliant...you got me psyched up for tomorrow!
 

Congratulations! If anybody deserves a find like that you do! By the way, in your video, was expecting a southern accent, but you have none. Where you from? Also, when you were quoting prices on a PB counterstamped Reale, I thought those prices were for an uncut specimen. Then reading about the one found in Mississippi I was surprised they fetch that kind of dough even being cut. A truly awesome find!
 

Last edited:
You really outdid yourself this time, congrats! What an outstanding piece to add to your collection, and it can only go up in value.
 

Now that's a find and a day that you'll cherish for many years, congrats on the great cut silver and the well deserved Banner.:hello2:
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest Discussions

Back
Top Bottom