What's new

The Treasure of Captain William Kidd.

There is great irony here.

Both Cryptid and The True Seeker both have the makings of very good researchers. Old Crow cannot give them both enough praise, but I see this....And it breaks my heart because I have seen it all before.

Cryptid is set on the idea that there is no such thing as buried treasure. And now he is set in that cognitive bias because he has a long history of that. When shown anything that contradicts his bias, he ignores it or dismisses it. In fact, that is what he has been doing all his life, hiding safely at home, finding excuses. As I have always said many times, research is key to getting to the truth as close as possible. One danger is building cognitive bias, and I will repeat, I and many others have at one time been guilty of it. There is no shame in it. I keep my mind open and still have my fair share of egg on my face.

The true seeker is fixated on Madagascar and believes only in buried pirate treasure, ignoring the Caribbean because it's not in his area of interest, so he ignores it and dismisses it. Both have cognitive bias and will ultimately fail. And that is sad because both have huge potential but will eventually go nowhere. If both of you think you are going to go through life and not make errors, then you are never going to ever live. Sure, get a history degree, then go and join the dole queue or flip burgers.

Bojai kindly offered a voyage to Madagascar, a trip of a lifetime. Truth Seeker wanted a set itinerary. The wind has no itinerary to follow, my friend; as Bojai and I know, the wind sets the itinerary. Predictability and seeking treasure do not go hand in hand. There are no guarantees in life.

Primary documents will always help build a good picture of what was happening. But it will never ever give you the full picture. Criminals do not follow textbooks written by academic authors. Academics never engage in real-world experience. Sure, there are smart criminals, and there are many dumb criminals. Some people post here who are too narrowly focused on topics that reinforce their bias. Sure, you can do that for your entire life doing that. Life is slipping you by; you can spend your entire life hidden away in rooms reading books and documents, dreaming. I know both of you in your hearts want to break free.

Go to these places and live it, and I will guarantee you will never feel so alive. And you will never be quite the person you were; success or failure does not matter because it's not about the destination; it's the journey that matters.

Bojai I see your monohull guy; they have their benefits, but I have gone over to the dark side. These days I am a cat guy. I sailed in many lagoon- and leopard-built catamaran vessels. This one lagoon I am considering buying. Excellent for the Pacific. I would not use them below the roaring forties. Monohulls rule high-latitude seas.

View attachment 2268865

She hauls ass and is nearly as expensive to maintain nearly as much as my other half.

One hard-learned lesson in life: never ever admit to finding treasure, not even a peanut. Nothing ever comes good from it.

I wish you all calmer seas and a good Christmas.

Crow

Some of the sources you are citing in this thread are from periods different from the one we are discussing. What people generally picture when they hear the word “pirates” are the pirates who operated during the Golden Age of Piracy. They sailed under pirate flags, made decisions by voting when there were disagreements among the crew, elected their captains by vote, and distributed their plunder almost equally. Kidd and Every were pirates of this era. Is that not this era of piracy we are discussing?

What are you trying to accomplish by bringing up records from 1578, 1610, and 1751? (As for the letter from 1716, even the author is unknown.) At least in this context, those sources are meaningless. You have utterly failed to understand this point. Before going around pointing out other people's biases, you should objectively examine your own actions.

As for your other comments, you are just criticizing others by forcing them into a convenient narrative that fits your own bias. Words like that have absolutely no meaning.
 
Last edited:
Historian E. T. Fox seems to have actually accessed the original document from 1707 (as there are expressions that are not included in the 1922 edition).
I was also able to find the following document. This is an excerpt from Joel H. Baer's British Piracy in the Golden Age, Volume 3. This book is a compilation of various primary sources from that era. (The use of the long s suggests that it was copied directly from contemporary records.)

What I take issue with regarding this document is not its content, but its authenticity. As I will show below, it is based on another document written by an associate of a man known to be a fraudster. Therefore, its credibility cannot be considered high.

Nevertheless, would it not at least serve as evidence that the concept of pirates burying treasure existed as early as 1707?
Thanks for the sources. Having now read the pamphlet in detail and understood the context (I should have done this earlier), it is clear that the capitalised word "Buried" functions as an economic metaphor for stagnant, uncirculated wealth (outside the British commercial system) rather than a literal description of buried or hidden treasure in/near Madagascar. Written by an early 18th-century economic lobbyist, the pamphlet reflects mercantilist anxieties at the time regarding dormant or stagnant wealth in Madagascar. The author explicitly pairs 'Buried' with 'Useless' (note both are capitalised for emphasis), establishing a rhetorical equivalence. Pairing words like this served as an equivalence: being "buried" meant "useless" because wealth removed from British commercial circulation was economically useless (capital removed from commercial flow generated no interest) and the British government (the Exchequer) could not tax or collect duties on it. The author argues that treasure (silver, gold) needs to be brought to England so that it can "Circulate to the Exchequer". In mercantilist terms in the early 18th century, wealth was only valuable if actively circulating within a national monetary system. Silver and gold deposited in banks, invested in stocks, bonds, or merchant shipping generated interest, funded commercial ventures, and built infrastructure. However, Madagascar, by contrast, had no central banking or investment apparatus meaning that Madagascan wealth in the early 18th century was locked outside of the British (and wider European colonial) commercial system and therefore was considered to be "buried and useless" or "dead capital", standing in stark contrast to the deeply integrated financial systems of the Caribbean at the time. "Buried" is thus an economic metaphor.
First, we should clarify the subject. I believe you are probably correct when it comes to Caribbean pirates active during what is commonly known as the Golden Age of Piracy. However, the historian Jan Rogozinski had already pointed out the differences between Caribbean and Indian Ocean pirates in 2000. (HONOR AMONG THIEVES p.233)
Rogozinski (2000) provides a decent summary, and mirrors closely what I was saying: "The buried treasure myth was created during the eighteenth century... Culminating in Treasure Island." My disagreement is the fictional literary tropes of pirates burying treasure and pirate treasure maps ("X marks the spot") date to the 19th century, not the 18th century, however, it could be that this was a typing error in the book and the author meant to say 19th century ("created during... culminating in Treasure Island" suggests 19th century since Treasure Island was published in 1883). As for the idea that pirates in Madagascar stored treasure for longer periods of time:
I have also personally discovered evidence that Golden Age pirates in the Indian Ocean kept their treasure in storage without spending it.
Of course, this document does not state that the pirates buried their treasure. However, it does provide evidence that Golden Age pirates in the Indian Ocean kept their treasure for years without spending it—or, more precisely, were unable to spend it.
The 1707 pamphlet mentions that pirates in Madagascar were "bestowing part of their Booties on the Inhabitants". Some pirates married into local Malagasy royal/clan families to secure safety and social standing. This would have included providing gifts such as treasure to these families, so this perhaps explains why some pirate treasure in Madagascar ended up in storage. Furthermore, the Malagasy economy was built around agriculture, cattle herding, and small-scale trade. A simple explanation is: the local market (such as livestock, crops, timber) could only absorb a tiny fraction of any wealth from pirate plunder so the rest had to be stored inside huts because there was no local outlet to spend it; in this sense treasure was not immediately spent by pirates. There is therefore a basis to what you are saying about Madagascar (treasure was stored longer) and I stand corrected. However, I disagree the pamphlet meant that pirate treasure was ever literally buried.
 
Last edited:
Hello Cryptid

You should really expand your horizons a bit more than falling into the academic trope that there is no such thing as buried treasure.
For lack of a better word, I have bookmarked the dozen or so historical sources you posted and will look at them in closer detail later, but I can immediately see: (a) some of them do not relate to pirates, (b) some are ambiguous English translations of Spanish documents, (c) some do not even mention that treasure was buried and (d) one looks like a forgery. I also agree with THE TRUE SEEKER that there is the issue that numerous sources you posted conflate completely different historical persons/groups, motives, behaviours, and eras. For example, the story recorded by the Franciscan friar Agustín de Cevallos in 1610 you quoted about a sergeant-major named Muñoz—is about a 16th century Spanish colonial expedition member. Muñoz was certainly not a pirate but a crown-appointed officer serving the Spanish Monarchy and he never attacked or robbed ships. According to the friars' account, in 1570, Muñoz found gold in indigenous burial places on land (meaning conquistador grave-robbing) and filled two large chests with it and buried or put them under a tree. The Spanish wording in the document:

The following excerpt was taken by photocopy back in the days before smartphones. Taken from Archives des Indes.

it took captain Munoz, sergeant of Perafan Ribera, governor and general captain thas was of Costa Rica, from seculchres that he found one league that entered in the coast, so quantity of gold that filled two big drawers of Castile, and greedy of more wealth, he wanted to enter with 60 soldiers in the inland and leaving buried near a tree the two drawers ...... walking a league, the indians killed several soldiers and he had to embark escaping as quickly as possible and leaving the two buried drawers and all theis soul, and there they are ........
From a letter of father Agustin Ceballos, Granada, Nicaragua, March 10, 1610
AGI (Seville), Section Panama, bundle 17 below
The "buried near [under] a tree" (or a similar) translation of the Spanish text is found in books but an alternative plausible translation of the words dej̄ando enterrados Al Pie de Vna ceiba is that the chests were wedged into the massive root buttresses at the base of the ceiba tree or its hollows. The latter makes more sense since the text indicates that Captain Muñoz’s unit was moving quickly inland. Digging a hole large enough to bury two heavy, iron-bound Castilian chests (cajones de Castilla) amidst the thick, interwoven root system of a giant ceiba tree without heavy entrenching tools would have been extremely difficult and time-consuming. Regardless of whether the chests of gold were buried or left under the tree's root buttresses, the document explains these chests were stashed temporarily because of an emergency. Muñoz stashed the two chests so his unit could travel light while marching inland ("quiso entrar... La tierra adentro"). When his troops were attacked and forced his retreat back to the sea, he was forced to flee without retrieving the chests so he did not plan to leave the chest for long. This means that the chests were only stashed as a very temporary logistical measure (obviously different to the fictional literary trope of pirates burying treasure). All that said, it is doubtful any of this actually happened. The friar was writing 40-years after the event and was relying on second-hand sources, but if it did happen, it is not even an example of a pirate burying treasure.

Privateer John Oxenham sailed with Sir Francis Drake, raided Spanish ships for gold and silver and was the first Englishman to build a boat in the Americas and to sail the Pacific - before meeting his end in the hangman’s noose. Now, his extraordinary tale, told in a contemporary manuscript of that era which records events from 1578-83, below, please look at the date of the document. September 1578
The 16th century document (the page you showed) does not mention treasure was buried:
Received on September 1, 1578 Most Illustrious Lords On September 1, 1578

Regarding the five thousand pesos of gold from the Englishmen that were seized in Panama.

The Englishmen reconciled by the Holy Office were named: Captain Juan de Hoznen [John Oxenham] = Juan Buthar [John Butler] = also named N. Chalona = and Henry Butler his brother = and Thomas Beroes Master = No. 30.


[Main Body Text:]
By order of Your Worships, I was notified that regarding the gold placed in my deposit—taken from the Englishmen who came to this South Sea—so that it might be secured at present, I should turn over 5,000 pesos, to be held in deposit under my care along with a command to [deliver it to] an authorized person until Your Worships should order otherwise. To which I answered as was fitting and appropriate, in full obedience to the mandates of the Holy Office.

After said order, the Royal Audiencia [High Court] of the said city ... certain individuals who owed gold pesos from my said deposit requested them and entered into a lawsuit with the prosecutor in the said Royal Audiencia ... and ordered them delivered. In execution of this, after four months had passed, charges amounting to about 800 pesos of fine gold were demanded of me to pay, under threat of imprisonment.

Having been served regarding this matter, I argued that these funds were granted and held in deposit by order of Your Worships, with strict instructions not to pay them under pain of major excommunication, and that I would answer for them in person or through a representative as someone compliant with the decrees of the Holy Office. I petitioned for a injunction directed to the said Royal Audiencia to remit my case back to the Holy Office.

But the Royal Audiencia, having reviewed the matter and considering the documentation presented regarding the lawsuit I had with Gaspar Pérez, a merchant from New Spain, ordered that I pay it so the mandates would be satisfied without charge. However, it was ordered that the bailiff arrest me, seize my property, and levy the costs of the proceedings upon me. This was carried out, and they have sold the enslaved servants (negros) of my household while I remain imprisoned, as Your Worships will see from the legal records attached.

I beg Your Worships to review this matter and instruct me on what I ought to do, as my intention and desire has always been to serve Your Worships. May Our Lord guard and preserve your Most Illustrious persons and increase your state. From Panama, July 7, 1578.

Most Illustrious Lords, Your servant,[Signed] Diego Madrigal "el Mozo" [or local notary/depositary]
I did look this up, and found the following: Joannes de Laet's Beschrijvinghe van West-Indien (1630) contains a chapter titled “De voyagie van Ian Oxenham Engelsman” (“The voyage of the Englishman John Oxenham”). The Dutch text says this account was supplied by a Portuguese informant and the relevant passage (relating to treasure) appears in this chapter. To summarise: the Spaniards followed the English up the Tuira river in Panama and then searched to find a hut where the English had left treasure: “een hutte van tacken ghemaeckt, daer de Engelsche al de schat geborgen hadden”. Translation: "A hut made of wood [branches] in which the English had stored the treasure". They were being pursued by the Spanish so left their treasure behind in a hut. I think you misread a website. The text at the bottom from this site ("They were eventually pursued upriver and were able to bury some of their treasure") is not a translation or accurate summary of the document. The earliest dated source to mention that the treasure was buried is Dottings on the Roadside, in Panama, Nicaragua, and Mosquito by Thomas W. Pim (published in 1869; pp. 167-168 [see below]). It tells the story differently. It states that the Spanish arrived at the place "where the treasure had been provisionally buried". This was not mentioned in the 1630 Dutch source and the variant tale of buried treasure dates to the late 19th century. Similar to the previous source you posted, in both of the Oxenham accounts (1630 and 1869) the treasure was left behind as a temporary or expedient logistical measure in the circumstance of a pursuit, rather than a long-term hiding place intended to preserve wealth for some future recovery. That distinction matters when comparing these sources with the fictional trope of pirates burying treasure for later retrieval for a different purpose. A temporary measure taken is not evidence of broader burial practice.

1792430134451.webp

1792430275796.webp

So are you still convinced that, in your words, all pirate-buried stories are just an invented fictional literary trope of pirates burying treasure that traces back to the 19th century?
Yes. Nothing you have posted refutes that. My view is more or less the academic consensus. One book I can recommend is Why We Love Pirates: The Hunt for Captain Kidd and How He Changed Piracy Forever (2020) by the scholar Rebecca Simon who emphasises that the popular image of pirates burying chests of gold and drawing maps with "X marks the spot" is purely fictional. She documents that the overwhelming majority of pirate plunder during the Golden Age of Piracy consisted of trade goods—cloth, sugar, lumber, tobacco, and alcohol—which would rot or ruin if buried. Treasure was also divided immediately among crew members as per ship articles and spent quickly at pirate-friendly ports like Nassau or Port Royal. As I noted in a previous comment, most pirates died within two to three years of taking up piracy; they lived fast and spent their money quickly; they had no long-term financial planning or motivation to hoard treasure underground. That said, there are some maritime historians, who as THE TRUE SEEKER points out, have argued that Madagascar was an exception and that pirates there stored treasure for longer periods. However, there is no evidence that pirates in/near Madagascar buried treasure or hid it underground, even if they stored it for longer. The mention of "Buried" in the 1707 pamphlet is an economic metaphor.

The Historical Society of Pennsylvania: Daniel Rolph stumbled upon a mysterious letter written in 1716 about a buried treasure. There is no doubt the note is authentic (shown below), but there are other questions being asked. The biggest ones being, ‘Was the treasure ever retrieved?’ or ‘Is it still there where the letter says it is, waiting to be discovered?’ But for us, the point in question is below. The letter was sent from St. Jago de la Vega, Jamaica. This location, along with the timing and contents of the letter, raises suspicions that the treasure is an actual buried pirate treasure! It is well known Jamaica was a favored location of many pirates traveling the seas in the late 17th and early 18th centuries But it is not proof of pirate treasure, although it does show the concept of buried treasure is much older than the 19th-century fictional book trope.
I am aware of this letter but it looks like a forgery. The Historical Society of Pennsylvania has no record explaining how the letter entered its collection. A document in a collection like this having no acquisition record is highly suspicious. Its filing card in the collection does not establish ownership prior to entering the collection so it has no provenance before 1996 (when a researcher said they stumbled across it in the collection). To my knowledge, there have been no tests to authenticate the age of the document and ink. There are possible linguistic anachronisms (20th century) in the document as well and these have been discussed elsewhere.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the sources. Having now read the pamphlet in detail and understood the context (I should have done this earlier), it is clear that the capitalised word "Buried" functions as an economic metaphor for stagnant, uncirculated wealth (outside the British commercial system) rather than a literal description of buried or hidden treasure in/near Madagascar. Written by an early 18th-century economic lobbyist, the pamphlet reflects mercantilist anxieties at the time regarding dormant or stagnant wealth in Madagascar. The author explicitly pairs 'Buried' with 'Useless' (note both are capitalised for emphasis), establishing a rhetorical equivalence. Pairing words like this served as an equivalence: being "buried" meant "useless" because wealth removed from British commercial circulation was economically useless (capital removed from commercial flow generated no interest) and the British government (the Exchequer) could not tax or collect duties on it. The author argues that treasure (silver, gold) needs to be brought to England so that it can "Circulate to the Exchequer". In mercantilist terms in the early 18th century, wealth was only valuable if actively circulating within a national monetary system. Silver and gold deposited in banks, invested in stocks, bonds, or merchant shipping generated interest, funded commercial ventures, and built infrastructure. However, Madagascar, by contrast, had no central banking or investment apparatus meaning that Madagascan wealth in the early 18th century was locked outside of the British (and wider European colonial) commercial system and therefore was considered to be "buried and useless" or "dead capital", standing in stark contrast to the deeply integrated financial systems of the Caribbean at the time. "Buried" is thus an economic metaphor.

Rogozinski (2000) provides a decent summary, and mirrors closely what I was saying: "The buried treasure myth was created during the eighteenth century... Culminating in Treasure Island." My disagreement is the fictional literary tropes of pirates burying treasure and pirate treasure maps ("X marks the spot") date to the 19th century, not the 18th century, however, it could be that this was a typing error in the book and the author meant to say 19th century ("created during... culminating in Treasure Island" suggests 19th century since Treasure Island was published in 1883). As for the idea that pirates in Madagascar stored treasure for longer periods of time:


The 1707 pamphlet mentions that pirates in Madagascar were "bestowing part of their Booties on the Inhabitants". Some pirates married into local Malagasy royal/clan families to secure safety and social standing. This would have included providing gifts such as treasure to these families, so this perhaps explains why some pirate treasure in Madagascar ended up in storage. Furthermore, the Malagasy economy was built around agriculture, cattle herding, and small-scale trade. A simple explanation is: the local market (such as livestock, crops, timber) could only absorb a tiny fraction of any wealth from pirate plunder so the rest had to be stored inside huts because there was no local outlet to spend it; in this sense treasure was not immediately spent by pirates. There is therefore a basis to what you are saying about Madagascar (treasure was stored longer) and I stand corrected. However, I disagree the pamphlet meant that pirate treasure was ever literally buried.

Thank you for your reply. The 1707 pamphlet states, “as Useless and Unprofitable as the Earth that covers it.” Considering that the word 'Buried' is used earlier in the passage, doesn't it mean that the author of this pamphlet intended for the treasure to be literally buried in the ground?


1000000371.webp
 
Last edited:
Getting back to what Bocaj states, which I agree with, just dismissing the "Avery the pirate" letters by the generalizing idea that "pirates will never bury treasure" is strange from someone who has done such deep research into something as questionable as the Palmer maps.

John Krill's papers are in the Library of Los Angeles

Tells of his failed search for alleged treasure connected to Avery.
As I noted in a previous comment:
The biographical pamphlet Note of John Knill 1733-1811, was not published until 1871. The earliest literary source I could find that mentions Knill was searching for Avery's treasure is dated 1848 (Rev. C. A. Johns, Week at the Lizard).
John Knill (b. 1733) died in 1811. He served as the Collector of Customs at St Ives, Cornwall, and Mayor of St Ives. A biographical pamphlet about him was published in 1871 (60-years after his death). The 26-page pamphlet was published by John Jope Rogers, under his initials J. J. R (p. 26). The pamphlet mentions that Mr. Knill in 1779 began searching for Avery's treasure on the coast of Cornwall (p. 9) based on a report that "Avery amassed a vast amount of treasure, and on one occasion was reported to have concealed in a cave, east of the Lizard point, certain chests of treasure" (p. 10). The problem is there is no document I can find or access from the 18th century or even first quarter of the 19th century that makes this claim. In 1838, the author Davies Gilbert (The Parochial History of Cornwall, p. 128) first mentioned Knill was searching for Avery's treasure. Rev. C. A. Johns, a decade later, in his Week at the Lizard (1848, p. 210) copied or paraphrased Gilbert's text:

1792500741128.webp


Gilbert (1838):

1792501116665.webp


The 1871 pamphlet (p. 9) in fact mentions Gilbert (1938):

1792516100143.webp


To sum up, there are three sources:

1792533742749.webp


These sources contradict each other when Knill supposedly obtained a treasure-trove grant. The Folk-Lore Journal (1887, vol. 5) quotes the Rev. C. A. Johns’s A Week at the Lizard (1848) which states Knill obtained a treasure-trove grant "about the year 1770" but the 1871 pamphlet (p. 10) dates the treasure-trove grant to post-1779.

The following are the main reasons I doubt there ever was a treasure-trove grant:
  • No Official Crown Grant (Patent Rolls): Grants of treasure trove were formal legal instruments granted under the Great Seal or Treasury warrants. If Knill was granted a Crown Grant c. 1770 or post-1779, a record should exist in the Crow Estate Papers or Patent Rolls (C 66) held at The National Archives. No such entry naming John Knill has ever been produced or cited with a TNA shelf mark.
  • No mention in Knill's diary: Knill is known to have kept a diary, yet nothing in it mentioned a treasure-trove grant or anything about him searching for treasure (if it had done so, it would have been quoted in later sources including historians who accessed the diary).
Why did Davies Gilbert make this up in 1838 (27 years after Knill's death)? There are at least two possibilities:
  • Eccentricity: By the 1830s, Knill had a posthumous reputation as an eccentric or oddball figure in Cornwall due to his 50-foot pyramid obelisk and dancing rituals. Local folklore could have exaggerated his attributed eccentric deeds (= searching for Avery's treasure).
  • Conflation with Official Customs Duties: As the Collector of Customs, Knill was responsible for dealing with wreckage and seized smuggled goods. In the early 19th-century, "wreck" and "treasure trove" could have easily been conflated in local speech. A routine seizure of contraband goods by Knill may have by word of mouth over years been distorted into "search for Avery's gold."
 
Last edited:
Thank you for your reply. The 1707 pamphlet states, “as Useless and Unprofitable as the Earth that covers it.” Considering that the word 'Buried' is used earlier in the passage, doesn't it mean that the author of this pamphlet intended for the treasure to be literally buried in the ground?


View attachment 2269040
The pamphlet was written by an economic lobbyist who wanted to persuade lawmakers that Madagascan pirates' wealth should be
brought back into England's commercial system to generate heavy customs duties (10% tax is mentioned on page 4). In this context, it makes more sense "buried"/"Earth that covers it" is not literal but an economic metaphor meaning stagnant wealth or immobilised capital—dormant and outside the reach of English (or British) commercial circulation and government revenue. There is another sentence in the same pamphlet that appears to contradict the literal interpretation of "buried"/"Earth that covers it":

For the Pyrates [Pirates] have by their long Abode there, and their Liberality in bestowing part of their Booties on the Inhabitants...

1792595964565.webp


If Madagascan pirates were actually burying their treasure, how could they have spent it locally or given it to Malagasy royal/clan families ("bestowing part of their Booties on the Inhabitants")? Also, against the literal interpretation of "buried" the pamphlet provides no specific burial location, incident of burying, named depositor, eyewitness accounts, or even a description of digging. The author of the pamphlet explicitly equates the treasure's utility to the dirt itself ("as Useless and Unprofitable as the Earth that covers it"). In 18th-century mercantilist thought, wealth that did not generate national customs duties, taxes, or trade is "dead capital" and was worthless to the nation as soil or dirt.
 
The pamphlet was written by an economic lobbyist who wanted to persuade lawmakers that Madagascan pirates' wealth should be
brought back into England's commercial system to generate heavy customs duties (10% tax is mentioned on page 4). In this context, it makes more sense "buried"/"Earth that covers it" is not literal but an economic metaphor meaning stagnant wealth or immobilised capital—dormant and outside the reach of English (or British) commercial circulation and government revenue.

The fact that treasures are disconnected from the English economic system does not contradict the fact that they are literally buried in the ground. That in itself does not serve as a rationale for denying that expressions such as "buried" were used in a literal sense.

If Madagascan pirates were actually burying their treasure, how could they have spent it locally or given it to Malagasy royal/clan families ("bestowing part of their Booties on the Inhabitants")?

The pamphlet states that the pirates gave a part of the treasure to the indigenous people. In other words, it is possible to bury the remaining treasure, for which there is no use, underground.

Also, against the literal interpretation of "buried" the pamphlet provides no specific burial location, incident of burying, named depositor, eyewitness accounts, or even a description of digging.

The purpose of this pamphlet is to provide an overview of the conditions faced by pirates in Madagascar, so the absence of specific descriptions is natural.

The author of the pamphlet explicitly equates the treasure's utility to the dirt itself ("as Useless and Unprofitable as the Earth that covers it"). In 18th-century mercantilist thought, wealth that did not generate national customs duties, taxes, or trade is "dead capital" and was worthless to the nation as soil or dirt.

There is no contradiction whatsoever in the treasure being "dead capital" and its being literally buried in the ground. The two are completely compatible.

Because the phrase "buried" and "as Useless and Unprofitable as the Earth that covers it." is used, it is clear that the author of this pamphlet literally envisioned treasure buried in the ground. The fact that treasure was useless to the English economy of that time does not disprove the idea that it was buried—because the two are not mutually exclusive. The interpretation that the treasure was "useless" and had become "dead capital" precisely because it was literally buried in the ground holds up without any problem.
 
Last edited:
Just dismissing the "Avery the pirate" letters by the generalizing idea that "pirates will never bury treasure" is strange from someone who has done such deep research into something as questionable as the Palmer maps.
The idea the four Kidd-Palmer maps are authentic has long been a non-starter, primarily because the premise of a "pirate treasure map"—complete with the iconic "X marks the spot"—is a fictional literary trope rather than a historical reality, the same for pirates concealing or burying treasure. Real-world pirates did not bury treasure, draw maps or leave behind written clues to find it; their goal was immediate liquidation and spending, not long-term concealment (although in Madagascar, for reasons outlined above treasure was perhaps stored for longer periods, but there is no evidence it was buried). In 2021, Dr. Simon Rebecca published an article debunking "common tropes and misconceptions about pirates": (1) pirates buried their treasure, (2) there was a pirate accent, (3) pirates made victims walk the plank, (4) women were [always] bad luck on pirate ships, and (5) all pirates flew the same flag (Jolly Roger). The first of these explains why there was never a debate among scholars about the authenticity of the Kidd-Palmer maps—historians recognised these documents for what they were as blatant fakes. For instance, when Rupert Furneaux first published reproductions of the Kidd-Palmer maps in the 1970s, they were swiftly dismissed by experts. In 1976, Alan Stimson, then Head of Navigation and Astronomy at the National Maritime Museum—commented directly on the maps, exposing them as obvious fabrications. Stimson emphasised that the concept of pirates burying treasure and sketching treasure maps belongs entirely to "romantic pirate tradition," a genre heavily popularised by Robert Louis Stevenson’s (1883) Treasure Island.

My personal interest in the maps was sparked because I am an armchair treasure hunter (that, and also because Harold T. Wilkins wrote about them; I own all his books including Captain Kidd and His Skeleton Island). As I mentioned in previous comments, my original view of the four Kidd-Palmer maps was they are an armchair treasure hunt in the vein of Masquarade or The Secret. There are examples of armchair treasure hunts based on an imaginary pirate-adventure setting e.g., Jim Hawkins and the Curse of Treasure Island (2001). The book includes a map and invites readers to identify the square where Jim unearths the treasure. A prize of £5,000 in antique sovereigns was awarded to a successful entrant in 2002 who identified the square on the fictional pirate treasure map.

1792628036340.webp

So there are definitely fictional pirate treasure maps in armchair treasure hunts that lead to a real treasure or a valuable prize (either buried/hidden boxes or chests like the casques [ceramic or metal cylinder/containers] in the The Secret, or that can be obtained by simply entering a master code or an answer to a puzzle online a website/"mail-in" solution). I originally thought the Kidd-Palmer maps were in the vein of The Secret, but as I explained elsewhere, over time, I grew increasingly sceptical of this. After I came across the Wild Cat Island and Rainbow Island fictional maps, it was clear the Kidd-Palmer maps are not part of an armchair treasure hunt but rather a forgery and the hoaxer fabricated a provenance (Pamela Hardy and Dan Morgan) for two of these maps. There is also the fact, the same forger was involved in forging hundreds of spurious Lord Nelson objects that were sold at auctions in the 1930s. If you are interested in finding treasure from maps, instructions, or clues, then try to solve an armchair treasure hunt. At least with these, you know there is an actual treasure and you are not wasting your time searching for something improbable or non-existent. Armchair treasure hunts do not predate the 20th-century but contrary to what many websites incorrectly state, they did not start with Masquarade in 1979, but trace back 75-years earlier to The Weekly Dispatch treasure hunts [1903–1904] (the Kidd-Palmer maps which date to 1927-1933 fall within that time period). I am currently trying to solve an armchair treasure hunt—The Hare on the Moon (unsolved since 2019). The prize is a unique golden hare painting worth £15,000. :coins:
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the sources. Having now read the pamphlet in detail and understood the context (I should have done this earlier), it is clear that the capitalised word "Buried" functions as an economic metaphor for stagnant, uncirculated wealth (outside the British commercial system) rather than a literal description of buried or hidden treasure in/near Madagascar. Written by an early 18th-century economic lobbyist, the pamphlet reflects mercantilist anxieties at the time regarding dormant or stagnant wealth in Madagascar. The author explicitly pairs 'Buried' with 'Useless' (note both are capitalised for emphasis), establishing a rhetorical equivalence. Pairing words like this served as an equivalence: being "buried" meant "useless" because wealth removed from British commercial circulation was economically useless (capital removed from commercial flow generated no interest) and the British government (the Exchequer) could not tax or collect duties on it. The author argues that treasure (silver, gold) needs to be brought to England so that it can "Circulate to the Exchequer". In mercantilist terms in the early 18th century, wealth was only valuable if actively circulating within a national monetary system. Silver and gold deposited in banks, invested in stocks, bonds, or merchant shipping generated interest, funded commercial ventures, and built infrastructure. However, Madagascar, by contrast, had no central banking or investment apparatus meaning that Madagascan wealth in the early 18th century was locked outside of the British (and wider European colonial) commercial system and therefore was considered to be "buried and useless" or "dead capital", standing in stark contrast to the deeply integrated financial systems of the Caribbean at the time. "Buried" is thus an economic metaphor.

The pamphlet was written by an economic lobbyist who wanted to persuade lawmakers that Madagascan pirates' wealth should be
brought back into England's commercial system to generate heavy customs duties (10% tax is mentioned on page 4). In this context, it makes more sense "buried"/"Earth that covers it" is not literal but an economic metaphor meaning stagnant wealth or immobilised capital—dormant and outside the reach of English (or British) commercial circulation and government revenue.

P.S. As you pointed out, even if the treasure was not buried underground, it was still disconnected from the British economy; however, this fact does not prove that the author of the pamphlet used the word "buried" in a non-literal sense. This is because the treasure being literally buried underground in or around Madagascar would also mean that it was disconnected from the British economy.
 
The fact that treasures are disconnected from the English economic system does not contradict the fact that they are literally buried in the ground. That in itself does not serve as a rationale for denying that expressions such as "buried" were used in a literal sense.



The pamphlet states that the pirates gave a part of the treasure to the indigenous people. In other words, it is possible to bury the remaining treasure, for which there is no use, underground.



The purpose of this pamphlet is to provide an overview of the conditions faced by pirates in Madagascar, so the absence of specific descriptions is natural.



There is no contradiction whatsoever in the treasure being "dead capital" and its being literally buried in the ground. The two are completely compatible.

Because the phrase "buried" and "as Useless and Unprofitable as the Earth that covers it." is used, it is clear that the author of this pamphlet literally envisioned treasure buried in the ground. The fact that treasure was useless to the English economy of that time does not disprove the idea that it was buried—because the two are not mutually exclusive. The interpretation that the treasure was "useless" and had become "dead capital" precisely because it was literally buried in the ground holds up without any problem.
If “Buried or Useless” and “as Useless and Unprofitable as the Earth that covers it” is to be interpreted literally, where is the independent historical evidence corroborating your claim that Madagascar’s pirates actually buried their treasure? What accounts identify pirates who buried their wealth, describe particular burial sites, record witnesses to such burials, or document subsequent discovery of buried caches? In the absence of such corroboration, it is difficult to justify treating these few lines of text as reliable evidence of a historical practice, let alone a widespread one (your comments imply Madagascan pirates commonly buried their treasure). The pamphlet was an economic and political tract. Its language must therefore be considered in the context of its purpose: the author sought to portray wealth remaining in Madagascar as economically unproductive. The imagery of treasure being “buried” and rendered as useless as the earth covering it can accordingly be understood as a rhetorical expression or metaphor. If you are going to continue ignoring this context and claiming Madagascan pirates genuinely buried treasure, and did so with sufficient frequency to constitute an established practice (to the extent this was known or heard about by the author of the pamphlet), the burden is now upon you to produce evidence supporting that claim. Why, then, should a single ambiguous paragraph in an economic tract be given such decisive evidential weight when no corroborating sources have been identified?
 
Last edited:
If “Buried or Useless” and “as Useless and Unprofitable as the Earth that covers it” is to be interpreted literally, where is the independent historical evidence corroborating your claim that Madagascar’s pirates actually buried their treasure? What accounts identify pirates who buried their wealth, describe particular burial sites, record witnesses to such burials, or document subsequent discovery of buried caches? In the absence of such corroboration, it is difficult to justify treating these few lines of text as reliable evidence of a historical practice, let alone a widespread one (your comments imply Madagascan pirates commonly buried their treasure). The pamphlet was an economic and political tract. Its language must therefore be considered in the context of its purpose: the author sought to portray wealth remaining in Madagascar as economically unproductive. The imagery of treasure being “buried” and rendered as useless as the earth covering it can accordingly be understood as a rhetorical expression or metaphor. If you are going to continue ignoring this context and claiming Madagascan pirates genuinely buried treasure, and did so with sufficient frequency to constitute an established practice (to the extent this was known or heard about by the author of the pamphlet), the burden is now upon you to produce evidence supporting that claim. Why, then, should a single ambiguous paragraph in an economic tract be given such decisive evidential weight when no corroborating sources have been identified?

As I mentioned before, what this pamphlet shows is that the idea of pirates burying treasure already existed back in 1707, which is independent of whether the claims in the pamphlet are true or not. It is not my original view that this document is evidence that the idea of pirates burying treasure already existed at that time, but rather it is something that the historian E.T. Fox has already pointed out.

1000000364-webp.2268216


Additionally, my position on the other points remains unchanged from my previous post.
 
Last edited:
History does by the fact of unreliable sources as further back you go and of non-state groups like nomads or pirates leave room for a lot of speculation. Simply stating that pirates never buried treasure can not be proven and is as such simply polemic.

Well I own a parrot (kind of) and I am a pirate so at least some pirate myth are real. If this stupid generalising discussion is carrying on I am honestly thinking of digging some hole in my beach and bury some treasure there so we can have a definite positive that disproves Cryptid.
 
As I mentioned before, what this pamphlet shows is that the idea of pirates burying treasure already existed back in 1707, which is independent of whether the claims in the pamphlet are true or not. It is not my original view that this document is evidence that the idea of pirates burying treasure already existed at that time, but rather it is something that the historian E.T. Fox has already pointed out.
If the idea or belief that pirates buried treasure in Madagascar was part of the public consciousness in 1707, we would reasonably expect to find it mentioned in other contemporary sources, particularly in accounts discussing the activities of Madagascan pirates, for example, the letters and sworn deposition (5 May 1699) of Adam Baldridge who set up a pirate base on Ile Sainte-Marie in 1690. Yet no corroborating sources exist, or at least have never been identified that mention pirates buried or concealed treasure on Madagascar. Baldridge's direct involvement in supplying pirates and receiving their plunder, means his account is a particularly relevant source but he does not mention anything about treasure being buried or hidden. This absence of evidence is significant because it leaves the pamphlet as an isolated piece of flimsy evidence for the literal interpretation, rather than demonstrating such a practice (pirates burying treasure) was commonly believed at the time or widely reported, regardless of whether true or not. Without independent corroboration, there is no reason to assume that the expressions “buried and useless” and “useless and unprofitable as the Earth that covers it” are intended as literal descriptions of pirates burying treasure or concealing it underground. It is more plausible that these expressions are economic metaphors describing wealth that has been withdrawn from circulation, and rendered unproductive.

As evidence for the metaphorical interpretation, I found some 17th to 18th century sources that use the language of burying money or wealth to describe its withdrawal from productive use or circulation. There are likely many more you can find and quote. These provide evidence that the word "buried" was being used at roughly the same time period non-literally; it could have an economic meaning apart from the claim that pirates physically buried treasure in the literal sense e.g,:
  • A Discourse of the Nature, Use and Advantages of Trade (1693): "while it remains in plate is of no more public benefit than if it were buried in the bowels of the earth”. The author discusses silver plate rather than being converted into coin. The silver is physically above ground, but its retention in plate makes it economically nonproductive/noncommercial as if it were buried.
  • Sir James Steuart, An Inquiry into the Principles of Political Oeconomy (1767) once uses “burying” figuratively when discussing money held in a bank vault: "how the burying, as it were, a quantity of gold and silver in a vault”. He discusses the Bank of Amsterdam. The use of the word "burying" is obviously not literal. This source demonstrates that an 18th century economic writer could use the vocabulary of burial to describe money being locked away in a bank (not underground) and unavailable for ordinary commercial use.
The 1693 and 1767 examples are especially useful because they demonstrate "buried" could describe economically inactive wealth without meaning that the wealth was literally underground, which is the most probable meaning of the 1707 pamphlet (a metaphor). As more evidence for the metaphorical interpretation, the passage must be considered alongside the pamphlet's purpose. The metaphorical interpretation explains the language in a manner consistent with the tract's economic subject matter. In such a context, the comparison between wealth and something rendered “useless and unprofitable” by the earth that covers it and treasure "buried or useless" makes sense as the consequences of wealth being withheld from circulation. The emphasis is on uselessness and unprofitability.

Finally, I earlier agreed with you that in Madagascar, pirates might have not spent their wealth so quickly (as elsewhere, particularly in the Caribbean) and stored it for longer periods (although there is no evidence for burial or concealment), however, the historical sources are actually conflicting or less clear about this now I have read more of them. For example, in A Cruising Voyage Round the World (1712), Woodes Rogers reported that the pirates remaining in Madagascar in 1711 were “very poor and despicable”. He estimated at that time, there were less than 70 pirates left or active on the island. There is also Adam Baldridge’s deposition of 5 May 1699 which documents exchanges of valuable goods and money between Madagascar-based trading networks and pirate crews between 1691 and 1697. Nothing in Baldridge's deposition suggests that wealth was stored but instead that pirates quickly exchanged goods and bought slaves for labour.
 
Last edited:
For those interested here are a few interesting sources on Captain Kidd including a recent publication:

The 95% Innocent Man: The Gray-Shaded Hero Captain William Kidd
By Samual Marquis

This article written by the ninth-great-grandson of William Kidd was published in International Journal of Naval History (August 2026).

Unfortunately, Maquis repeats the false claim that Kidd buried treasure on Gardiners' Island:

Captain Kidd at this time also buried a portion of his legally obtained treasure on Gardiner’s Island with the permission and assistance of the island’s proprietor, John Gardiner. Like their captain, Kidd’s crew was anxious about Lord Bellomont and wanted to safeguard their earnings since they were wanted men and did not trust the governor or any other Crown official. Thus, Captain Kidd’s ‘treasure’ was distributed to key individuals and safely buried purely as a precautionary measure since neither he, his wife, nor his men trusted Bellomont. Meanwhile, he kept much of his silver and gold, jewels, and bale goods with him aboard his new ship, the St. Antonio.

Olmsted and Captain Kidd's Treasure
Article on the Astor fortune hoax published in the Liberty Magazine (24 February 1934).

The story was made up by Franklin Harvey Head, an American lawyer and author. It appeared in his pamphlet A Notable Lawsuit (1898) and was earlier presented as a talk to the Chicago Literary Club in 1896. According to the hoax:
  • Kidd buried treasure on land in Deer Isle, Maine, associated with the family of Frederick Law Olmsted.
  • A trapper discovered the treasure and sold it to John Jacob Astor.
  • Astor used the treasure as the initial capital that enabled him to establish his enormous fortune.
  • Generations later, the Olmsted family sued the Astor family for the value of the stolen treasure.
The alleged lawsuit was itself part of the hoax and there is no evidence of the Olmsted-Astor legal dispute as having occurred.
 
Last edited:
If you look in The National Archives' catalogue

SP - Records assembled by the State Paper Office, including papers of the Secretaries of State up to 1782
Division within SP - State Papers Domestic, Charles II to George III
SP 36 - Secretaries of State: State Papers Domestic, George II
Subseries within SP 36 - LETTERS AND PAPERS
SP 36/116 - Letters and Papers.

You will see actual recovery of buried pirate treasure on Norman Island in


Folios 29-30. Report from the legal officers to Bedford about the rights of ownership to treasure captured by pirates from the Spanish and buried on Normans Island [British Virgin Islands].

Reference: SP 36/116/2/29
Description:

Folios 29-30. Report from the legal officers to Bedford about rights of ownership to treasure captured by pirates from the Spanish and buried on Normans Island [British Virgin Islands].
Date: 1751 June 4
Held by: The National Archives, Kew
Legal status: Public Record(s)
Language: English
Closure status: Open Document, Open Description
So if the claiming the concept of buried pirate treasure did not exist prior to 19th-century fiction writers, then this above 1751 record should not exist?

As I am aware 1751 falls in the 18th century, prior to the 19th century.
The problem is you have not shown the actual document (a 1751 report) to verify if buried treasure was mentioned. This document is not digitised and the catalogue entry states it can only be accessed in person from The National Archives. I found a book from 1894 purporting to summarise the contents of this report but this is a secondary source published 143 years later and its accuracy is questionable. The first known search for treasure on Norman Island dates to 1835 (Norman Island Treasure Company). Note that treasure hunting companies or corporations and organised commercial ventures to search for pirate buried treasure did not emerge until the 19th century. In the preceding century there were only naval salvage syndicates. This is evidence that the idea or belief of pirates burying treasure was not in the public consciousness in the 18th century. If it was, why were there no organised commercial ventures in the 1700s to dig up buried treasure?
 
Last edited:
Hi, I'm a little late to this thread, having just seen the Avery overlap of late - (so catching up now)
Kressen Kernow Document J/1/2277 watermark has been discussed recently.... it's a partial year, being "18".

(more things to share soon over on the Avery thread, after my next Kressen visit)

1793540380824.webp
 
It looks like I was correct to doubt the claimed 1818 date of the watermark. Only "18" is visible. The contents of the letter instead suggest a mid-late 19th century date and that the writer was influenced by adventure romance/pirate fiction.
 
I think people in general buried “treasure” during times of chaos or for safekeeping from others. Look at all these hordes found throughout Europe of ancient coins.
I find it amusing when people speak in absolutes, ie “A pirate has never buried treasure, ever”. I find folks who speak in absolutes have absolutely no idea what they’re talking about or little actual experience besides regurgitating what they read from someone else who also speaks in absolutes.

The fact is no one knows what’s out there and who buried it. So regardless of what anyone has to say on here, the advice & opinions are worth what you paid for it, absolutely nothing.
Ancient and medieval coin hoards were frequently buried or concealed by individuals seeking to protect their wealth during periods of war, invasion, political instability and other threats to their personal security. This historical practice cannot be extrapolated to 17th or 18th-century pirates, whose circumstances and economic incentives were fundamentally different. Piracy was usually a short-lived occupation, with a pirate's active career on average lasting only two years, with high risks of capture, execution and shipwreck. Pirates had a strong incentive to quickly spend, distribute or exchange their plunder than to bury or conceal it at some indefinite point in the future. Plunder from ships was rarely even suitable for burial because it was not predominantly gold and silver coins but consisted of spices, textiles, silk, wine, tobacco, and sugar. These are vulnerable to either moisture, mould, insect consumption, and deterioration when buried underground. Their commercial value would be diminished or destroyed through prolonged storage in such conditions. They were instead intended to be immediately sold or exchanged, not buried or concealed underground.

A Roman citizen concealing his wealth in the form of coins during an invasion, and a pirate in c. 1700 supposedly burying the plunder acquired from a successful raid on a merchant ship, are two fundamentally different historical propositions. The former is well documented and supported by archaeological discoveries and historical literature; the latter lacks any evidence. There is no sound reason to assume that a practice documented among civilian populations during periods of insecurity was also customary among pirates, whose economic circumstances, lifestyles and incentives were entirely different. The question is why should the idea of burial of pirate treasure be accepted as an established historical practice in the absence of evidence, particularly when there is considerable historical and economic evidence that proves pirates generally sold, exchanged, distributed or spent their plunder quickly, rather than buried or concealed it?

I argue that the persistant belief in pirate buried treasure is attributable to the illusory truth effect: the psychological phenomenon whereby repeated exposure to a claim increases the likelihood that people will perceive it as true, irrespective of the supporting evidence (there is none). For generations, the fictional image of pirates burying treasure and treasure maps ("X marks the spot") has been repeatedly reinforced through novels, films, television, video games, and popular culture. Through this constant repetition, a 1900s literary fictional trope that later spread like a contagion across electronic media has been confused with a historical fact in the minds of many people.
 
Ancient and medieval coin hoards were frequently buried or concealed by individuals seeking to protect their wealth during periods of war, invasion, political instability and other threats to their personal security. This historical practice cannot be extrapolated to 17th or 18th-century pirates, whose circumstances and economic incentives were fundamentally different. Piracy was usually a short-lived occupation, with a pirate's active career on average lasting only two years, with high risks of capture, execution and shipwreck. Pirates had a strong incentive to quickly spend, distribute or exchange their plunder than to bury or conceal it at some indefinite point in the future. Plunder from ships was rarely even suitable for burial because it was not predominantly gold and silver coins but consisted of spices, textiles, silk, wine, tobacco, and sugar. These are vulnerable to either moisture, mould, insect consumption, and deterioration when buried underground. Their commercial value would be diminished or destroyed through prolonged storage in such conditions. They were instead intended to be immediately sold or exchanged, not buried or concealed underground.

A Roman citizen concealing his wealth in the form of coins during an invasion, and a pirate in c. 1700 supposedly burying the plunder acquired from a successful raid on a merchant ship, are two fundamentally different historical propositions. The former is well documented and supported by archaeological discoveries and historical literature; the latter lacks any evidence. There is no sound reason to assume that a practice documented among civilian populations during periods of insecurity was also customary among pirates, whose economic circumstances, lifestyles and incentives were entirely different. The question is why should the idea of burial of pirate treasure be accepted as an established historical practice in the absence of evidence, particularly when there is considerable historical and economic evidence that proves pirates generally sold, exchanged, distributed or spent their plunder quickly, rather than buried or concealed it?

I argue that the persistant belief in pirate buried treasure is attributable to the illusory truth effect: the psychological phenomenon whereby repeated exposure to a claim increases the likelihood that people will perceive it as true, irrespective of the supporting evidence (there is none). For generations, the fictional image of pirates burying treasure and treasure maps ("X marks the spot") has been repeatedly reinforced through novels, films, television, video games, and popular culture. Through this constant repetition, a 1900s literary fictional trope that later spread like a contagion across electronic media has been confused with a historical fact in the minds of many people.
What actual facts do you have that pirates never buried their treasure?

None. It’s solely your opinion.

Again. You speak in absolutes with literally ZERO facts and/or evidence. You’re simply arguing a point that cannot be proven.
 
What actual facts do you have that pirates never buried their treasure?

None. It’s solely your opinion.

Again. You speak in absolutes with literally ZERO facts and/or evidence. You’re simply arguing a point that cannot be proven.
Cryptd1990 has hundreds of posts of containing empirical facts.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom