What's new

The Treasure of Captain William Kidd.

What actual facts do you have that pirates never buried their treasure?
None. It’s solely your opinion.

Again. You speak in absolutes with literally ZERO facts and/or evidence. You’re simply arguing a point that cannot be proven.
I already explained: absence of evidence is evidence of absence when evidence would reasonably expected to be present if the proposition were true. There is a common misconception that absence of evidence can never constitute evidence against a proposition but if a particular event, activity or phenomenon occurred, and we would reasonably expect it to have left some observable or documentary trace, the failure to find such evidence is relevant to assessing the probability that the claim is true or even falsifying it. To provide an example: suppose someone claims that a substantial military invasion took place on Iceland during the 1800s. We would reasonably expect an event of this magnitude to have generated contemporary evidence e.g., military correspondence, government records, newspaper reports, eyewitness accounts, other historical documentation as well as physical evidence. If extensive Icelandic records from the relevant period survive (they do), yet contain no reference to the alleged invasion, that absence is obviously not meaningless nor is the absence of archaeological evidence. On the contrary, it constitutes convincing evidence to a high threshold of proof (beyond reasonable doubt) against the assertion an invasion took place because a military event of that scale would reasonably be expected to leave a considerable documentary footprint.

The above reasoning applies to the evidence-free assertion that pirates buried their plunder, drew treasure maps ("X marks the spot") or the claim there was a widespread belief they did in the 17th-18th centuries (when in reality, pirate treasure maps and pirate buried treasure are 19th century fictional literary tropes popularised by authors like Robert Louis Stevenson [Treasure Island (1883)]). If pirates burying treasure was a historical practice or there was at least a widespread belief or rumours it was happening at the time during the Golden Age of Piracy, we reasonably would expect to find corroborating contemporary accounts, eyewitness testimony, or at least sources that mention it and/or archaeological evidence of these burials. The sheer absence of such evidence, when considered alongside contemporary literary evidence of how pirates actually disposed of their wealth by spending or exchanging it and the fact pirate plunder was predominantely not gold or silver but things that were not suitable for burial or storing underground (such as textiles), is relevant to evaluating the credibility of the claim.
 
Last edited:
I already explained: absence of evidence is evidence of absence when evidence would reasonably expected to be present if the proposition were true. There is a common misconception that absence of evidence can never constitute evidence against a proposition but if a particular event, activity or phenomenon occurred, and we would reasonably expect it to have left some observable or documentary trace, the failure to find such evidence is relevant to assessing the probability that the claim is true or even falsifying it. To provide an example: suppose someone claims that a substantial military invasion took place on Iceland during the 1800s. We would reasonably expect an event of this magnitude to have generated contemporary evidence e.g., military correspondence, government records, newspaper reports, eyewitness accounts, other historical documentation as well as physical evidence. If extensive Icelandic records from the relevant period survive (they do), yet contain no reference to the alleged invasion, that absence is obviously not meaningless nor is the absence of archaeological evidence. On the contrary, it constitutes convincing evidence to a high threshold of proof (beyond reasonable doubt) against the assertion an invasion took place because a military event of that scale would reasonably be expected to leave a considerable documentary footprint.

The above reasoning applies to the evidence-free assertion that pirates buried their plunder, drew treasure maps ("X marks the spot") or the claim there was a widespread belief they did in the 17th-18th centuries (when in reality, pirate treasure maps and pirate buried treasure are 19th century fictional literary tropes popularised by authors like Robert Louis Stevenson [Treasure Island (1883)]). If pirates burying treasure was a historical practice or there was at least a widespread belief or rumours it was happening at the time during the Golden Age of Piracy, we reasonably would expect to find corroborating contemporary accounts, eyewitness testimony, or at least sources that mention it and/or archaeological evidence of these burials. The sheer absence of such evidence, when considered alongside contemporary literary evidence of how pirates actually disposed of their wealth by spending or exchanging it and the fact pirate plunder was predominantely not gold or silver but things that were not suitable for burial or storing underground (such as textiles), is relevant to evaluating the credibility of the claim.
Absence of evidence is not evidence.

I’ve never seen a baby pigeon, but there are adult pigeons all over NYC. Based on your post since we don’t see baby pigeons, pigeons shouldn’t exist. Doesn’t make sense. Does it.

PS I can use ChatGPT too.
 
It looks like I was correct to doubt the claimed 1818 date of the watermark. Only "18" is visible. The contents of the letter instead suggest a mid-late 19th century date and that the writer was influenced by adventure romance/pirate fiction.
The water mark most likely ascertains that the paper it is written upon was created in 1818 ! whilst the section of watermatk does just show "18", what year is that going to be in than century other than 1818 ?, all writing upon it must have been after... The contents include 2 parts, the itinery of conciled treasure in one part (which is duplicated word for word in the other Avery related document found in Scotland), the shared part being possibly possibly being Corenlieuss FFurssons itenery of the content of chests dating back to 1702!.

Back on thread !!

The overlap of threads here, concern If the "WK" in the Avery doc may be William Kidd - I dont see a point in recorded history that the timelines that Avery and Kidd could have met post Avery Gunsway heist, to share that information...

(albit i've not read the majority of these 55 pages before - please enlighten me if i've missed something, and should read back ...) I've not see anything yet that suggests W.K. was multi-lingual, Is there anything else that has been attributed in the french language ?
 
Absence of evidence is not evidence.

I’ve never seen a baby pigeon, but there are adult pigeons all over NYC. Based on your post since we don’t see baby pigeons, pigeons shouldn’t exist. Doesn’t make sense. Does it.
Seeing adult pigeons is evidence that baby pigeons do exist—adults do not spontaneously materialise out of thin air. The claim that people never see baby pigeons is simply false; a quick search on YouTube reveals videos (including from New York) and there are photographs and eyewitness accounts. Did you even bother to read or comphrehend what I said about absence of evidence being evidence of absence when we would reasonably expect evidence to be present? I provided an example (the claim an invasion took place on Iceland in 1800s).
PS I can use ChatGPT too.
I do not use ChatGPT for my forum comments. ChatGPT is American and uses American English. I am not an American and you can see British English spelling in my comments like my previous comment e.g., "rumours" as opposed to "rumors". Aside from the fact I use British English, note there are spelling errors in my comments (like my previous). Do you really think the word predominantly would be misspelt as "predominantely" (you quoted in my previous comment) on ChatGPT? Furthermore, I spend considerable time typing out my comments (I do not do a quick copy and paste) which explains why I can be seen browsing forum threads for so long and I also try to justify the text of my comments (where both left and right margins are evenly aligned) which is not ChatGPT's web interface output for text. Having looked at your comment history, I do not think you are here to be constructive but wind people up. For that reason, you are going on my ignore list.
 
Last edited:
Seeing adult pigeons is evidence that baby pigeons do exist—adults do not spontaneously materialise out of thin air. The claim that people never see baby pigeons is simply false; a quick search on YouTube reveals videos (including from New York) and there are photographs and eyewitness accounts. Did you even bother to read or comphrehend what I said about absence of evidence being evidence of absence when we would reasonably expect evidence to be present? I provided an example (the claim an invasion took place on Iceland in 1800s).

I do not use ChatGPT for my forum comments. ChatGPT is American and uses American English. I am not an American and you can see British English spelling in my comments like my previous comment e.g., "rumours" as opposed to "rumors". Aside from the fact I use British English, note there are spelling errors in my comments (like my previous). Do you really think the word predominantly would be misspelt as "predominantely" (you quoted in my previous comment) on ChatGPT? Furthermore, I spend considerable time typing out my comments (I do not do a quick copy and paste) which explains why I can be seen browsing forum threads for so long and I also try to justify the text of my comments (where both left and right margins are evenly aligned) which is not ChatGPT's web interface output for text. Having looked at your comment history, I do not think you are here to be constructive but wind people up. For that reason, you are going on my ignore list.
Don’t waste your time trying to convince me one way or the other about pirates burying their loot. They may have or they may not have. You can’t prove it either way and I simply don’t have interest in your argument.

Your posts are AI heavy. It is quite obvious.
 
It is unfortunate this thread has been derailed by someone repeatedly posting false claims against me. In their own words, they admit they have "no interest" in my arguments so what are they doing here and responding to me? It seems they are only here to insult and provoke me. Suffice to say, I am not putting up with this abuse and have now reported their comments. None of my comments are AI-generated.
 
Cryptid1990:

Do not pay attention to those who believe in fantasy and try to derail logic based on actual facts.

Please continue with your excellent research.

I've added the problem party in question back to being a member of my Ignore list as their posts have no relevance to the topics presented and they just wish to have someone pay attention to them.
 
Cryptid1990:

Do not pay attention to those who believe in fantasy and try to derail logic based on actual facts.

Please continue with your excellent research.

I've added the problem party in question back to being a member of my Ignore list as their posts have no relevance to the topics presented and they just wish to have someone pay attention to them.
Thanks, appreciated. I should clarify, that the reason I take exception to the untrue allegation my forum comments are AI-generated is I am a staunch critic of artificial intelligence who is opposed to it for a number of reasons (I will not go into these as it is offtopic). I am in fact, one of the first individuals to have filed a lawsuit against an AI chatbot and this is documented on numerous law websites and in books. I am known for my "anti-AI" views and AI proponents have labelled me as a luddite. Although the lawsuit I filed was dismissed by the judge, I succeeded in the sense that the company I sued (for promissory estoppel) updated their AI chatbot to include a disclaimer about possible inaccuracies when asking the chatbot questions and so they conceded it was defective. I very rarely therefore use AI, and if I do, it is to test or probe it to find flaws. For example, I used it briefly back in April to highlight "problems with AI algorithms being fed misinformation".
 
Last edited:
Thanks, appreciated. I should clarify, that the reason I take exception to the untrue allegation my forum comments are AI-generated is I am a staunch critic of artificial intelligence who is opposed to it for a number of reasons (I will not go into these as it is offtopic). I am in fact, one of the first individuals to have filed a lawsuit against an AI chatbot and this is documented on numerous law websites and in books. I am known for my "anti-AI" views and AI proponents have labelled me as a luddite. Although the lawsuit I filed was dismissed by the judge, I succeeded in the sense that the company I sued (for promissory estoppel) updated their AI chatbot to include a disclaimer about possible inaccuracies when asking the chatbot questions and so they conceded it was defective. I very rarely therefore use AI, and if I do, it is to test or probe it to find flaws. For example, I used it briefly back in April to highlight "problems with AI algorithms being fed misinformation".
I had a hunch you were a lawyer or were in the field of law at least. You argue points that really don’t warrant an argument.

It also makes sense that you are suing AI companies. Your degrees are becoming about as useless as outhouse wallpaper thanks to AI.
 
The water mark most likely ascertains that the paper it is written upon was created in 1818 ! whilst the section of watermatk does just show "18", what year is that going to be in than century other than 1818 ?, all writing upon it must have been after... The contents include 2 parts, the itinery of conciled treasure in one part (which is duplicated word for word in the other Avery related document found in Scotland), the shared part being possibly possibly being Corenlieuss FFurssons itenery of the content of chests dating back to 1702!.
To my knowledge, dated watermarks do not appear as only two digits, unless the original fours digits were partially lost through cutting or folding of the paper. So for example, "18" appears on one half and "50" on the other ("1850"). I have never seen just two digits as a year abbreviation. The "18" on the paper (based on its position) does not look like it has been cut or folded:

1793710018475.webp

Where only two digits appear (excluding if they were partially lost), a possible explanation is that this is a mould number. Sometimes two digit numbers like "18" were wire-stitched into the paper to track pairs of the paper moulds (e.g., mould 18) independent of a year date. However, this is not conclusive. While you are correct for obvious reasons writing on the paper would have taken place after a watermark and the manufacture of the paper, it was usually the case that people in the 18th to 19th centuries used/wrote on paper shortly after the paper was manufactured and they did not stockpile it for long periods of time; see Peter Bower, "A Survey of the Time between the Making of Writing Paper and its Use", The Quarterly, no. 52 (October 2004), pp. 31-47. Bower's study reported (out of a sample size of 90, covering the period 1754–1851) that the arithmetic mean (average) was 3.1 years meaning the interval from the time the paper was manufactured or it left a paper mill and its use (when someone wrote on it). The range did not exceed 11 years. In other words, if an 18th or 19th century document with writing was not dated by the writer but the paper has a watermark, this is an approximate year the document was written.
 
The piece of paper has two fairly straight edges, the top, and one of the sides. The edges which meet at the corner where the watermark is, are both much rougher, This photo is taken from the back, and i've altered the contrast a little to show tears and folds more clearly (please excuse my hand)

1793722275462.webp


It's possible that the piece of paper was originally within a notebook/sketchbook similar to the i'll copy a photo of below, (which is the same size, and common within the archives at Kressen, there are thousands of them theren) the straight cut longer edge being the outer most edge - this one is older, dates indicate around 1803.

1793723126318.webp
1793723222729.webp
 
Your posts are AI heavy. It is quite obvious.
That's funny, I came to the opposite conclusion. Crypt's research has been both solid and revealing. If it offends your beliefs, then that's for you to work out, or not.
 
The paper is obviously "laid" paper, which was phased out in the early 1800s. It would naturally have slightly rough edges, so those are probably the original frame edges. As such, the "`18" is likely the entire watermark and it is probably not a date but something else. However, it is also highly likely that the paper was made before 1830, maybe well before.
 
That's funny, I came to the opposite conclusion. Crypt's research has been both solid and revealing. If it offends your beliefs, then that's for you to work out, or not.
Congratulations. What do you want a cookie?

It doesn’t offend my beliefs friend. He just won’t listen to a differing opinion. That’s all.
 
So offer some evidence!

Here's something... in 1573, Sir Francis Drake buried a bunch of gold & silver in Panama after he raided a Spanish mule train. It was too much to carry during the retreat so he buried it

Another one: in 1927, a treasure hunting team took a Chilson bridge (early metal detector) and located buried "pirate treasure," again in Panama. Was it Drake's?

I know more about these, but I'll offer you the fun of researching them to find out more. Who knows, maybe they'll lead to other buried pirate treasure.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom